John Warburton
John Warburton, the Founder & CEO of Konsileo, discusses the new three pronged approach that Konsileo is applying towards virtual insurance "broking" as they call it across the pond!
INTRO
On episode 11 of the InsurTech Geek Podcast, talking about Virtual Insurance Brokering with John Warburton from Konsileo.
INTERVIEW
JAMES: Creating salutations to everybody out there in InsureTech world. I hope you are doing well I hope you had a wonderful Christmas and New Years and enjoy the beginning of the year. Can you believe it is already in February of 2020? I had a unique date the other day, right, it was 2, it was 02/02/2020 February 2nd, 2020. That just happened, that did not happen for the last 900 years so if you date a math nerd you will enjoy the fact that you had a unique date recently. Also, that is the year 2020 and this is supposed to be when all crazy things happen like, flying cars and bionics and all kinds of stuff that we kept on being promised in science fiction movies. And they not quite here yet but we do have a lot of other cool stuff and one of those things that we are going to be talking about is of course out of the cool world of technology is InsureTech. And today we get to talk about it with a cross pond episode we have a Brit. That is right the ladies and gentlemen we have a Brit on the show. His name is John Warburton. John, how are you doing?
JOHN: I am very well thanking you James, and it is lovely to be on your show.
JAMES: Ah, lovely to have you on the show. Always good to have someone from the mother ship, from Queen's country.
JOHN: The people who speak the correct English you mean.
JAMES: The Queen's English, yes, that is the correct English, it is the correct English, yes. My English teacher might senior year of high school was Mrs. Smith. And Mrs. Smith was from England as well and she made it very clear from her first day of teaching with us, that we would be learning the Queen's English for that year. And this was before, this was back in the 90s right, this was before they before the educational system got so standardized that teachers didn't have any latitude, and so, she taught us what she wanted for a year, and she thought me, that woman Mrs. Smith that my favorite English teacher "-"
JOHN: I think the problem might have been, the thing that we all do when we go to America, is we all we speak a little more received pronunciation. We all speak a little poseur just to impress you Americans. If you listen to people speaking to each other over here, it is a lot less elegant then Mrs. Smith. She was probably from the east end of London and a real Cockney
The full transcript
Transcribed automatically from the episode audio, so some names and terms may be misheard.
James BenhamOn episode 11 of the InsurTech Geek podcast talking about virtual insurance brokering with John Warburton from Konsileo. The InsurTech Geek podcast powered by JBKnowledge is all about technology that's transforming and disrupting the insurance world. We'll be interviewing guests and doing deep dives dives with our own r and d team in the technology we see changing the industry. We're taking you on a journey through insurance tech. So enjoy the ride and geek out. Greetings and salutations everybody out there in InsurTech world. I hope you're doing well.
I hope you had a wonderful Christmas and New Year's and enjoyed the beginning of the year. Can you believe it's already into February 2020? Had a really unique date the other day. Right? It was, '2 what what was February. 02/02/2020. That just happened. It was that's not that didn't happen for the last nine hundred years, so you data and and math nerds will enjoy the fact that you had you had a unique date recently. Also, that it's the year 2020, and this is supposed to be when all kinds of crazy things happen like flying cars and bionics and all kinds of stuff that we kept being promised in science fiction movies.
And they're they're not quite here yet, but we do have a lot of other really cool stuff. And one of those things that we're gonna be talking about is, of course, out of the cool world of technology is InsurTech. And today, we get to talk about it with a cross pond episode. We have a Brit. That's right, ladies and gentlemen. We have a Brit on the show. His name is John Warburton. John, how are you doing? I'm very well. Thank you, James, and it's lovely to be on your show.
Oh, lovely to have you on the show. Always good to have someone from the mothership, from Queen's country. The people who speak the correct English, you mean. The Queen's English. Yes. Is the correct English. It is the correct English. I my my English teacher, my senior year of high school, was missus Smith. And missus Smith was from England as well, and she made it very clear in her first day of teaching with us that we would be learning the Queen's English for that year. And this is before this was back in the nineties.
Right? It was before they
John Warburtonyou know, the educational system got so standardized that teachers didn't have any latitude. And so she taught us what she wanted for a year. She taught me that woman, missus Smith, my favorite English teacher. I the problem might have been the thing that we all do when we go to America is we all speak a little more receive pronunciation. We all speak a little posher just to impress you Americans. Actually, if you listen to people speaking to each other over here, it's a it's a lot less elegant than missus Smith.
She was probably from the East End Of London and a real cockney. She she Exact.
James BenhamShe put it on for you when she came over the pond. She did. She put on the Queen's Eagle. So there's there's a good bit of putting on that goes on with both British and Australians. We've we've had a lot of Australians on our other podcast, the content crew. We only work in two industries, construction and insurance, and they they have intersections all over the place. So we we get to work with Brits and Aussies and all kinds of and and The key cultural insight into the Brits is the end of the film Love Actually.
That's every Brits' fantasy when they come to America,
John WarburtonDid you know if you know the bit I'm I'm referring to?
James BenhamI do, and that's hilarious. Go for it, man. I tell you what. It's
John Warburtonthat that is that is keen insight into the British mind right there. That that is that is it. That's why that's why that's sustaining half the tourist industry that comes to comes to The US. Doesn't matter how many visa restrictions you put in front of us, Steve. We we think we've got accent arbitrage that we're we're over.
James BenhamMan, that no one has ever said that to me, but that is that is truly hilarious. You know, Aussies put it on too when they come here. I mean, big time. Yeah. But no one can understand what they say, so it's fine. Exactly. And they constantly confuse them for being British. And then Exactly. Poor South Africans, you know, we have we have an office in South Africa, and we have a lot of British South Africans and Dutch South Africans. And the British South Africans, no one can tell where they're from.
They they they guess Australia. They guess England. They never guess South Africa. But you you are you are one of the Queen's people. So we're we're gonna talk about you first, and then we're gonna talk about insurance tech. And we're we're gonna kinda dive into the bits and pieces behind the technology that's driving a lot of change and what you call broking or what we call brokering, yet another difference. It's like when y'all say go to hospital. What happened to the pro what happened to the article the, the hospital?
You know, you you're going to the store. You go to hospital.
John WarburtonCan you explain that to me? I really can't. And, you know, to be honest, that's the first time I've really considered that we don't put the hospital in front the in front of hospital. That is true. I'm going to hospital. You're going to hospital? The generic the generic hospital, I suppose. Yeah. Like, which hospital? It's it's so confusing. It's almost like you turned hospital into a verb. Anyway, beside the point, let's go back to this, and let's talk about you.
James BenhamWhere were you born and raised? Where'd you go to school? Now you had a you had a stop at a school I'm not fond of, so we're gonna talk about that. Yeah. I I went I was lucky that I'd had a stint at the best university in in America, actually, which was great for me.
John WarburtonBut before I went to that one no. I'm I'm originally from Plymouth in the Southwest, which many people on your side of the pond will be familiar with, where the Mayflower sailed from and so on. Yes. So my my my father was in the military or in the navy. And but then he left and became an insurance broker, so I've got it in my blood, really. And grew up there and then in just South Of London when I was a bit older. I went to university.
My undergrad, I went to a place called the School of Oriental and African Studies where I studied Middle Eastern politics. And I was also in the military as well myself. I was gonna join the Navy and go and become James Bond. That was my plan. And so learning Arabic and and learning where things were in The Middle East so that I would be better prepared to go and do military things was was was what I was doing. But we had lots of defense cuts, and I decided not to do that and ended up in an insurance company when in 1993 was when I joined the insurance industry.
So I think I'm quite a bit older than you. And then, yeah, I went through the normal insurance company stuff. I worked for a company called Commercial Union, which is now part of Aviva. And then then I went when I was 23, I went with them to Hong Kong and then to Beijing. So I was in East Asia for best part of three years, which was a really formative time for me and a lot of fun as well-being 23 of that. And I was actually there talking of British things.
I was in I was actually, I'd I'd already left living in Kong. I was living up in Beijing, but I came I was there in Hong Kong on the 06/30/1997.
James BenhamDo you know what happened then? Oh, one of the worst days in Hong Kong history.
John WarburtonWell, I don't that's a matter of opinion on which depending on which side, but certainly, it caused the wrench for me. So, yeah, this for your listeners' benefit, this was the day that Hong Kong was handed over from British sovereignty to
James BenhamChina. So sad.
John WarburtonAnd I was there the last that was the last day of the British Empire, the last vestiges of the British Empire, basically, seeing that flag come down. But I will tell you my Hong Kong handover anecdote. So we on that day, we'd been out in a company junk, terrible rain. The the prince Charles was there to do the handover, and it was a big ceremony. But I I went with some friends to a nightclub in not far from where the ceremony was, and we went, you know, just typical nightclub type stuff, playing regular dance music.
And then they had the TVs on silent in the corner of this club. And as it was getting towards midnight, was a bit like the sort of thing you get in, you know, at New Year's Eve. So you were counting down towards midnight, and they had the TV on silent. So you could see then that they they they cut across to the TV and they paid, you know, god save our gracious queen. So they they you know, the as the as the Union Jack was coming down.
And then as that had come down, the Chinese flag was just starting to raise, and the DJ in the club turned off the TV sound and started playing Always Look on the Bright Side of Life by from the film The Life of Brian. Always look on the bright side of life. And that was my that was the end of the British Empire, and I was there to witness it. Oh, you were there. Oh my gosh.
James BenhamSo, you know, it's it's tough doors,
John Warburtonthen I just carried on being an insurance guy. As an Anglophile,
James Benhamyou know, I'm not British, but I pretend to be one sometimes. And I am I'm half English. And I I love I love Great Britain. I I think it, you know, I think it's a pretty cool place. And I love going to London. Finance and insurance are big to big big business in England. Yeah. It's big. It's mean, in many ways, it's the it's the center of the, let's say, globalized
John Warburtonbit of an insurance industry. So Mhmm. You know, Lloyds of London and all that and most the reinsurers. I mean, obviously, Munich and Swiss Re have big, big capital, but I think it's a more international insurance market than than sort of bits around Hartford and and New York and so on. So, yeah. No. It's pretty interesting. Yeah. A it's fascinating place, and, of course, you know, the companies that led the expansion of the British Empire, there there was a very interesting public private partnership between the British Empire expansion between the British government and then all the different development companies that that went with them.
I think this is interesting, actually, when you see it. So I I worked for this company, Commercial Union, which was one of those legacy kind of, you know, started in the colonial times companies. And what what's interesting is you go around Asia, Malaysia, you know, Hong Kong, Singapore, Australia, and then into even the bits that weren't necessarily colonized by the Brits that were influenced in Thailand. And you see the same basically, the same policy wordings, the same structure of insurance products, and so on, particularly, not so much in in consumers business, but in commercial insurance, it's pretty much the same wherever you go because of the Brits, because we went around and basically put these structures in based on copy pasting policy terms and policy conditions from The UK practice in the nineteen twenties, thirties, forties, that sort of thing.
So, yeah, actually, as a insurance person, if you learn as I did, if you learn how, you know, your insurance in in The UK, it's pretty transportable around most bits of certainly Asia.
James BenhamAnd actually, funnily enough, even in even in when I then later on in my life, I worked in Germany and even in Germany, Italy, Spain, to be honest. There's very there's a lot of commonality in commercial insurance terminology because it kind of was exported by the Brit, more And or I love and I love looking at the history of things. I'm I'm a history nut, and I listen to lots of history podcasts and read lots of history books. And I like to know where we came from so we can understand where we're going.
So I'm a I'm a futurist technology company owner who's been writing code for thirty years who is obsessed with historical historical accounts of things. And it's fascinating because, you know, the the Romans and the Greeks really were the originators of of of insurance, and you get done to, like, bottom re contracts that the merchants of Babylon used six thousand years ago. Yeah. And it basically all comes out all comes out of marine cargo, doesn't it? Yeah. It does. Genesis of it all. Yeah. It was all marine cargo, and then ancient Roman law recognized bottoming contracts, and then the Greeks really did the first known actual insurance contracts, but it was all about maritime cargo.
But then, of course, you know, the Great Fire of London, 1666,
John Warburtonthe that was the big originator for fire insurance and for property insurance. Exactly. So you get all these fire marks. But it's very tragic, actually. We've got this lovely institution called the Chartered Insurance Institute, which is like the professional body, awards the the certification. You you get the the sort of associate ship or the fellowship, which is, you know, you then you can call yourself a chartered insurance broker. And they had this lovely headquarters. It was not that old. Was like a 100 years old, but it had all these fire marks up the staircase from all these old companies because, know, after the fire of London, different insurance companies would have their own fire brigades.
There wasn't municipal fire safety. So they would have a fire mark on the side of a building, and they would if these guys had fire engines, you know, which is like a horse drawn thing, and they'd they'd have a pump, and they would go past the way if there was a fire, they'd go past the ones that would have the other people's fire marks on, and they'd go to the one that had their fire marks. So you were basically and then this has kinda come full circle.
You were you were buying insurance, but you're also buying a Yeah. Risk management I was gonna say you're buying loss prevention as well. Right? Yeah. Loss prevention or loss mitigation at least. And so we've come full circle. You know, it's now possible to buy those sorts of things. I think that sort of goes to the heart of my my thesis around insurance breaking, really. We're here to manage risk, not to sell insurance. And you're seeing that actually interesting. California,
James Benhamthere's a lot of companies that sell private fire protection services for wildfires. And, of course, there's a lot of public outroar because they're like, well, why are you passing the other houses? Well, those houses paid for private fire service in addition to paying taxes that pay for the public fire service. But there was a good bit of discussion and argument. But, you know, no no discussion of insurance in England and anyone English is complete without talking about Lloyd's. Right? Mhmm. Seventeenth century starts as a coffee house.
And it's just wild to think of it that Edward Lloyd and a coffee house would start something so big. And so you, you know, decide not to go in the military. I, by the way, had a similar choice. I was in the Corps of Cadets today, and I Navy was midshipman, which means I was a cadet as a college student. I had the choice to commission as an officer. And I chose not to because Bill Clinton was president at the time, and he wasn't hiring. They were in the same thing, military drawdowns.
And so Mike Well, it was the don't tell the days of don't ask, don't tell, wasn't it? Yeah. It was a wild it was a wild, different military, and it was a it was a very different military, it was a very different hiring policy, very different staffing policy, and so they weren't hiring. And so it a lot harder to get a commission, in particular in the areas I was interested in. And so I started, you know, my software company, and you had a similar choice. You chose to to deep dive into insurance, which led you interestingly to to Hong Kong.
What what happened after Hong Kong and Singapore and all that? So I was I was Hong Kong, Beijing. So I came back in
John Warburton1998. Then I worked for a couple of years in the, like, London head office of of commercial union. They went through a couple of mergers, and I ran a personal lines book, which was a sort of affinity buzz so, you know, motor home and motor insurance. Yeah. It looks like you got caught up in the .com boom a little bit in '99. I did. Yeah. I did a thing for about, well, overall about two years, but really full time, sort of six to eight months. So my dad, as I said, he was he was in insurance.
So he had a he had a funny little brokerage business that did a bit of this and a bit of that, but they had a bit of travel insurance they did, and I said, let let's scale this. We can sell travel insurance direct to consumer on this, their interweb thing. And this is pretty early days to do a transactional. We were the first ones to do a transactional, you know, e commerce. Yeah. '99. Yeah. That was pretty early. It was it was called goshore.com. It's great because you could get good URLs back then, and that was moderately successful.
In the end, some other guys came along a bit more money. But interestingly, we we got so I I went and went off to business school for a couple of years after that, like, you know, was just a fill in really for six months. But funny, my dad sort of took it on, and this guy worked with us. My brother did it for a bit as well after college. And and this guy went said, oh, you know, worked with worked with my he was a friend of my brother's, went off and said, oh, can I do the same thing in Australia?
And he went off and did it with the with the technology partners, and he's now, I think, the second the biggest one in Australia. Nice. So so he's got he's, like, a couple 100,000,000. It's or at least a 100 and something million. So, yeah, he did really well with it. So so, no, that was quite fun. And then I went to business school, and then as I say, I went to London Business School. Well, hold on. In the great state of Texas. Yes. So I went to the the real university in Texas.
Not the one. The the university of Texas is not the one that teaches people how to mend agricultural machinery.
James BenhamSo you did learn something over here. You learned how you learned you learned how to smack talk like a Texan, which I appreciate.
John WarburtonSo so for for the listeners out there, I I So I was at University of Texas in Austin, which is the Yeah. Oasis of of civilization in your fine state, I believe. It it is. It is. It is. It's an island. By the way, what brought you to Texas and UT? I just really fancied that I there was a list of what was places you could go on exchange. Went for six months. I mean, I was doing you know, my my degree was in London, but I I I just really fancied Texas.
I just thought it was the most American place you could possibly go. It is. And so I had a I had a blast there, and I was there in the February, the Dimpled Chad election with George W. And and Al Gore. It was fascinating. Yeah. Hanging Chads, Dimpled Chads. Dimpled Chads, hanging Chads. That was an exciting time. Everybody felt like a like a like a insurance underwriter
James Benhamspecifying endorsements in a binder. Right? Like Yeah. If it's if it's halfway off, but not all the way off, is it still a hanging Chads? I must admit, with with being
John Warburtonslightly annoyingly British about it for a moment. I was a bit amazed at the time that people didn't back off. I was surprised that the response from both sides was to send 300 lawyers each to Florida. It's like, you you would have thought the appearance of legitimacy is almost as important as the result, you know No. Anyway. No. That's No. Let's just let's just win. Yeah. That's that's not the way it went down. No. Exactly. You spent after school quite a bit of time at Alliance.
And So I I was at Accenture for a bit, a few years Yep. Which quite it's just good training if you've been to business school and, you know, you learn how to do PowerPoint, basically. And kids were on the way, so I thought, right. Get out of consulting. It's a bit too much travel. And I got this job as the head of sales and distribution for Allianz, UK business, which was called Allianz Cornhill at the time. And and I was there on and off for a few different guys' from 2004 to 2011.
And what was really interesting about that time, and I had few different sort of added marketing to it and product development and sort of expanded it a little bit. But the I was on the board of the commercial. So the way it was structured in The UK, you had the commercial insurance business and the personal insurance business. And what was really interesting about that time was there was a lot of consolidation, a lot of roll ups going on in The UK at that time amongst brokers.
So what was happening was we would would have these reasonably stable portfolios of business, and we were paying, I don't say, 17 and a half percent commission on average or 18, you was the typical for a commercial combined policy or 10% for fleet and these sorts of levels of commission. And these guys would buy using private equity money, would buy up these breaking firms and come and knock on our door and say, oh, yeah. You know these portfolios that are 17 and a half percent? Yeah.
It's not anymore. It's 30. I said, what? 30? Not like 20. No. No. No. 30. We're gonna up it to 30. In fact, we'd like to do some work transfer, so we're gonna add more value to you. So let's just call it 35. Woah. And we were we were we were sort of gobsmacked, you know, the management team. And and, of course, it's a strategic issue, and it's really interesting from an economic point of view because what was happening was this was between there there was a reasonable concentration.
I mean, there's a lot of personal lines carriers in sorry, commercial lines carriers in The UK, but there were five or six dominant, you know, companies. One of know, Allianz was, I think, the third or fourth biggest at that point. I think it's now the second biggest. And and so, you know, there's that whole prisoner's dilemma issue going on. So, you know, if they jump and they go for this thing, then we'll be left behind. We'll lose our volume. And I think there's a fantastic article actually about insurance called the Journey by McKinsey.
I don't know if you've ever seen that. Have you ever read that? I have not. It's the seminal treaties on how to run a good insurance company, and what it says is don't chase the volume, chase the profitable business, basically. So if if you're gonna give up volume, then don't don't don't do it. But there's this dysfunction at the heart of insurance companies, which is we've got a fixed cost base. We don't want our expense ratio to rise. Therefore, we've got to keep the premium up rather than address the cost base.
And what you should do is just keep your cost base reasonably stable and let the volumes fluctuate according to what pricing you can get. That's a better way to run an insurance company than, you know, be worried about the ratio rising slightly. But anyway, we got sucked into that vortex and they all were. And what happened was people it was prisoner's dilemma. People broke. You know? They said, yeah. Yeah. We'll pay 30. And then be before you know it, you you just have this rising tide of commissions.
Very scary. And what what I noticed back at that time was that these guys who were going around and buying up these firms, firstly, you know, they were they were basically using the insurer's money to pay back the the the debt and the private equity. So we were feeding it. You know, it's a kind of Frankenstein's monster phenomenon. But, also, this was really interesting. These guys weren't adding anything when they did it. They were just literally it was literally a roll up, and it was literally a a supplier by, you know, buyer power type play, and the insurers were the only target, really.
So the clients weren't getting any better service. In fact, they were probably getting worse service and the staff, and this was the key thing, the staff were getting disenfranchised because they were working in 30 person organizations. They might have one day thought of becoming a partner or a director of that firm, and suddenly they're just assistant branch manager in some provincial bit of a backwater in this bigger organization, but there's none of the benefits of being in a big organization. So that was my key kind of insight, if you like, that that period was that this broking was just fundamentally a flawed model in terms of where the value creation was done.
Yeah. Basically, they they held them hostage. They said, hey. We're big and bad now. We're giant, and you're gonna pay more percentage because we want it. Yeah. I mean, from from my point point of view at the time, it was like, well, you know, they're screwing the insurers. But, I mean, insurers have fought back a bit, but so you shouldn't feel too too sorry for the insurers. I mean, it's their own mistake that they said yes. But what they were also doing, the collateral damage was the client relationships and the staff.
What they were never doing was they were never investing in operational change in technology. So they were kind of doing the roll up and then stopping at the level of managing the portfolios, optimizing the portfolio and the placement strategy, and that was it. They weren't doing anything to address the inefficiencies in the organizations, you know, the operational processes, the proposition to their staff, the proposition to their clients, etcetera, and all those things were kind of left where they were or they worsened because there was, you know, fewer choice, less choice of insurers or, you know, basically, the internal mechanisms in all these firms became largely about have you met your budgets for placement with insurer A, insurer B, insurer C?
So it became this sort of disenfranchising of the professional whole of market risk advice that these guys that these broking people, these producers, and these brokers could do. In other words, they weren't placing the client's risk needs as the primary priority. Yeah. They were going through the motions of doing that, but it was within a restricted portfolio of preferred markets. And then, in addition, they they then got a bit even greedier. They wanted to go from 30, say, 32 to 37 or 40%. So then they said, hey, we've got this brilliant idea.
We're going to create a managing general agent and we're going to consolidate our book into, you know, even smaller number of insurers. And then there would be pressure internally to use the captive facility that was within these things. So you've got this kind of, you know, rising tide of commissions, which of course in the long run is pretty unethical and pretty it's against the interest of the client because the client ends up paying away 40, well, plus the insurer's own cost, know, 45 to 50% before any claims are paid.
Yeah, but the real issue too is ultimately, risk managers got wise to all this foolishness. The big ones did. The big ones did, but the middle ones, they didn't have that much choice. But what typically found was that I read this report actually with the Chartered Insurance Institute a few years ago, and we got a bit of data. And what was interesting was about four or five years ago or even better, say, seven or eight years ago and onwards, there's, you know, like sort of mushrooms, the smaller firms started to grow market share relative to these consolidated ones because the clients were not happy, some staff would leave, they would take the clients with them, etcetera.
So, you know, there's a certain organic nature of the insurance broking market where, you know, business is fundamentally sticky to individuals. And and so, you know, these these large consolidator plays where they've got this rather rigid structure that there's a there's a sort of diseconomy of scale at the at the end with those, and that's what you're starting to see now. Although the game is still being played in exactly the same way with PE money, we're a lot of consolidation going on still in The UK market.
There's sort of second wave and third wave of these guys because it's a pretty easy way to make money, apparently, until it comes home to roost. So one of the biggest consolidators had a had financial difficulty about eight years ago, seven or eight years ago because, you know, it's just an unsustainable kind of pyramid. Sure. Well, it depends on someone else buying you out eventually. That's the game. That's their thought. Yeah. The real game is acquire
James Benhamthe real game is we're gonna get a higher multiple if we have a bigger book of business than we would if we have a smaller book of business. Exactly. And if we can drive margins up and if we can drive commissions to our producers down, we can pump our spread and then take our multiple up three or four points
John Warburtonfrom where it was and, you know, make a killing. I mean, it's And that's not wrong in terms of the there is an economy of scale in broking. The problem is the primary the only lever of economy of scale that brokers really that these consolidating brokers were really playing on was buyer power versus insurers. You know? So they were walking past economies of scale in technology, development and support and process reengineering. They're walking past economies of scale, which don't really exist that heavily, but, you know, in branding.
But certainly, they were, you know, in proposition or in staff training or staff wellness or any of these other things that might be actually levers you could use to make yourself a better organization. They were just focusing in on the on the buyer power thing as the most the most obvious one. So anyway, so so it was kind of an interesting time I spent with back then in in that period, it was a very time of massive change in The UK market. Sure. And eleven years at Allianz, and and then you decide to So that was up to 2011.
Then 2011, I went then 2014. I was actually based in Germany. I was so I was promoted to this role, which was I worked for the chief marketing officer, and this was a time when Allianz were really thinking hard about, you know, what does it take to digitize? I mean, we would now say insurtech, but then there wasn't a word. But it was like, what can we do that's digital? What what can we do? You know, Allianz, the biggest after the demise of the first, the post financial crisis AIG kind of collapse and then rebirth.
So Allianz, I think, was the biggest property and casualty insurer. Well, biggest insurer, full stop, sorry, life and property and casualty. And, you know, massive global player, not so big in The US, a few bits and pieces in The US, but more more, you know, definitely European, Asian, pretty big, etcetera. So so, you know, what how can we digitize? And the really inch and so this was an interesting role and, you know, it had a lot of prominence, real board board connection. My boss reported to the global CEO, and then there was a, the operations as chief of the COO was really into it all as well.
So we had a big sort of, you know, we've got an appetite to invest. They've the wherewithal to invest hundreds of millions, as Allianz have done subsequently as well, in this, you know, internal change. You know, do we work with startups? How are we going to crack this nut when what we realize is that or what, you know, the Allianz generally realizes, you know, we've got these massive books of business which are really dependent on on on personal relationships. And now this was more, you know, the the consumer businesses, particularly in places like Germany, Italy, Spain, France, they have these models which aren't it's not broker models.
They have tied agents. And tied agents, if you drive through any of these countries, you'll see, you know, Allianz, AXA, Generali, offices, because these are, you know, basically single company single company face to face selling of the mainstream insurances, you know, home and motor and and agriculture insurance or whatever for for all the the people in those countries. And, of course, transitioning that to be something digital without losing the intimacy of it being a face to face connection was a big deal. But what was interesting for me is and so we tried loads of things, you know, different forms of how you could digitize the the these guys.
And I was sort of driving it from the global perspective, but the and in each country, they had really interesting experiments on how to make this this happen. And I think for me, what made me decide to start Konsileo was I had the basically, this insight into these problems of commercial insurance broking in The UK. And what I also learned, by the way, when I was in Germany was that actually commercial insurance I knew this kind of anyway. I knew The US market a little bit.
But commercial insurance broking is pretty much done the same way where if you go in the world, it's basically a producer, somebody back in the office who sorts out the paperwork for them, and they go out and see clients and the clients love them for years and years and years. That's basically it. And then they have insurer relationships that they can place the business with, and it's exactly the same wherever you go, whereas if you go into the consumer market, very different wherever you go in the world.
So, you know, some people buy insurance online, you know, like Progressive in The US, Direct Line in The UK, people in Germany, Italy, France, they tend to buy from these tight agents, although direct is emerging. There are some sometimes there are insurance brokers involved in that in the consumer space, sometimes there aren't. But in the commercial insurance, it's pretty much all insurance brokers. So I had all these learnings from doing the more international stuff, and I was in lots of countries, know, Australia, across the whole of Europe, a little bit in The US, Brazil.
You know, it was really interesting. And so took those learnings about how you can wrap technology around people, but, you know, with this sort of human in the loop insights that the human was pretty important to the proposition, so how do you wrap technology around them? And then I started thinking, okay, there's that problem that I saw back in 2004 to 2011, which, you know, this consolidation problem, these guys are vulnerable, and I put the two together and basically said, insurance broking in The UK is fundamentally broken.
The issue is that the value creators are not really aligned with the organizations that they're they're working with. And so that was my kind of insight, and then I started thinking about that, came back to live in The UK in 2015 and met my cofounder few beers and chats about what what the issue was, and my cofounder was a tech guy, we we iterated around on it for best part of a year, but basically where we ended up was if you're to address this issue of how to align value creators, I.
E. The producers with the company, we need to have a technology a different way of doing the processes through technology because the prevailing model of how brokers are organized via they all bought one of four software providers, that that model is broken And that model is holding back, so you cannot innovate. In The UK anyway, it's very difficult to innovate on how you do insurance brokerage because the systems are organized in a particular way, which is a kind of twenty to thirty year away go way of organizing.
So it's how to bring modern process insights into insurance broking. So we then spent a couple of years building the system, and and and then we started trading as a broker, you know, about eighteen months ago, two years ago. And the whole premise behind Konsileo is tech enabled
James Benhambrokerage that is all about serving the client needs and taking care of the producer? I mean, it it sounds like Yeah. Exactly. So looking at both sides of the equation. Right? Yeah. The key the key thing we so
John Warburtonso we have three sort of three things we believe about broking. The first one is the person is more important than the brand they work for. So, you know, a commercial insurance broking, I'm talking about the mid market now. I'm not talking about what next insurance and, you know, the the or simply business in The UK do. I'm not talking about, like, one like, a a mobile hairdresser or a or a person with one van. You know? I'm not talking about those. That that will go direct, they don't need advice, really.
They just need to buy cheap insurance. And I'm not really talking about, like, the global the Fortune 500 companies. I'm talking about the guys in the middle, in between those two, which is a lot of companies and a lot of turnover. And and what they typically need so so so so those guys, they trust the person that deals with them. They don't really care what's on that person's business card. Not really. So, you know, there's a lot of loyalty to the producer. So that's the first the first point.
People are more important than brand. The second bit is that advice and data are valued by consumers, by business owners. Now the advice part we know is definitely true. That's the proposition at the moment. That's clear. The trick is to get them to buy into the the the better data will help them. Now that's a bit more of a hypothesis. That's a bit more difficult to prove because that's not the prevailing offering. But, you know, over time, you can nibble away at that. Here's a bit of extra data.
Is this useful to you? Here's a bit of extra data. Here's a bit of extra data. So data plus advice plus data is valued by by clients. And then the third piece is that broker data is superior to insurer data. Now that's not a statement of the world as it is, but it's a statement of how the world should be. And for the very simple reason that if brokers have data, because they're earlier in the risk identification analysis process, they will that that is better for the outcome of the overall underwriting process.
And the the the simple example is if there is something about that risk, for example, there was a regulatory inspection out, we call them the health and safety executive is the thing in The UK. And there was a regulatory inspection into one of your factories two years ago, and there's publicly available data about that inspection. If you have that data, when you go to see the client and you say, oh, I can see you had an inspection here that they they found some health and safety issue that's reported on on the online database from the government.
If I can find it, your insurer can sure as hell find it. So please tell me everything about that and what happened in the mitigation. You blending third party external data with the insights from the company? And then you package that together, then you send it to the underwriter. That's a lot better than the underwriter coming in later and saying, oh, I noticed there was an inspection two years ago by the government regulator. What happened? And you go, oh, sorry. We forgot to ask them that.
Oh, oh, mister client, what happened? And then you're going back back and forth. It's at best inefficient, at worst. Nobody spots it. The claim happens. They try and repudiate the claim, you know, professional errors and omissions claim against the broker and everyone's unhappy. So broker data is better than insurer data could be just because they're earlier in the chain and they can augment it with insights from the client. So there's three things. So we've got the people are more important than the brand, data plus advice plus data is valued by clients, and the broker data is superior to underwriters.
And then with those insights, we then built our proposition, which is kind of a three ways story to the producers as probably the primary one because they're the people who do the value creation and they get the clients ultimately. So it's to them, be the happiest, best rewarded, and most professional broker you can be. And then it's to the clients, and that's about the advice plus this data. And then to the insurers, it's about being a fair and straightforward trading partner, so we don't do the please give us 35% game, but it's also about we are actually adding value to your risk analysis and identification as we go through.
And we've put weight terms of our business model, but also our technology behind each of those three elements of our proposition.
James BenhamThat's that's good stuff. And I I I wanna focus in on broker data better than the insurer data. Yep. Because we're seeing certainly really large sophisticated risk managers going fixed price on their brokered services. They're they're doing RFPs, and they're they're getting and they're getting a lot of responses. There are lot of brokers that are willing to come in and work for them at at a at a fixed price and no commission. You know? And and we're we're seeing that quite a bit. I was a city councilman in my city for six years.
We had a, you know, a good sized city, 120,000 people. We spent $380,000,000 US a year in our budget. So we we had a decent risk management budget. And we we had fixed price brokerage and TPA services. We unbundled everything. And, you know, you're seeing a a good bit of that, and there's a lot of brokers that are in a bit of an arms race right now to try and figure out how to continue to justify, really, their their role in the world. Uh-huh. Because let's be honest, there there are a lot of brokers.
There's a lot of really good ones out there, but there's also a lot that, you know, work really hard to get the account and then email their client a PDF form to fill out every year and then send it to the existing underwriters and just try and just try and get it renewed. They don't shop the insurance every year. In fact, they'll they'll tell their client, oh, no. You shouldn't shop your insurance every year. It really upsets the underwriters and etcetera, etcetera. And I think this goes to the heart of the proposition.
It's like, what does an insurance broker exist to do? And the and the the clue is slightly in the name. It's like,
John Warburtonbroker is such a disreputable word because it just means middleman. Right? It means that, like, you know, if you just knew that and at its very worst, which is, you know, why it's being eliminated in some of the more commodities classes, commoditized classes, if you and that's why these tight agents in Germany and France, you know, if only sell Allianz policies and Allianz put up a website saying, Get your insurance here, why would I go to the guy with a mustache called Gunther who's gonna take hours to do it because he's got lots of paperwork to fill in and he's gonna charge me more?
Why wouldn't I just go to Allianz's website and do it? You know? It's like so if if if there's no value add in the advice, then why would you pay for it? That and that's the key thing. So we we're really about transitioning insurance broking. And and in the commercial space, it is it is more more the case, you know, from transaction enablers to risk advisers. Right? You've got to add something to the risk adviser. Now most half more than half of the well, the vast majority of the proposition is delivered by the skills and professional expertise of people who actually know what they're talking about.
So they go into your factory or your business, and they look around and they say, oh, you know, you've got this exposure, you've this exposure, you've got this exposure. I can see that. I can, oh, tell me about your the machines you use. Oh, yeah. Okay. And how is your health and safety policy? And that that that that. But so there's there's a lot about the expertise. But our insight is that, yes, that's true. And that that whole identification of risk and then structuring it so that then the insurers can quote against the against certain product types.
That that's that's a value adding activity. But in addition, certain tools that can help that business to monitor and manage that risk and giving them data back is really, in addition, is interesting to that client over time. And then then you're getting them into a much more value value adding relationship because you are helping them to manage that risk in a proactive way rather than just being a chain, being a step in the purchase of the of the coverages from the insurance Yeah.
James BenhamLook, I went through the .com boom. I am a few years behind you, but I went through the .com boom, as did you. And there were many that predicted twenty years ago that the broker would go the way of the dodo bird because of the Internet, because of websites. And that didn't happen. Okay. That that let's just say that did not happen. But technology It is did in certain segments, and I think that's that's It did in in certain segments. I mean, you have you have for example, you have home insurance companies.
You have auto insurance companies here, For sure, The United States where you can directly write and bind. You have commercial insurance providers, I mean, that that you contact on the web. You quote it out on the web. They can quote you in a minute and bind you instantly for commercial insurance. I mean, so it exists, but there's still a massive brokerage business out there. But you are seeing brokers put a lot more emphasis on technology. Let's talk specifically about the technology, not about the not about the frameworks you selected to build in, not about the database structure.
Like, we're not we're not gonna know, that that's maybe that's a conversation for Peter. It looks like that's the role he plays in your firm. But Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. He's a CTO. Yeah. Yeah. So and he's looks like he has a fascinating background, but let's let's keep it to high level. Mhmm. What specifically are y'all developing that's really changing the game for your clients and your producers?
John WarburtonSo so so the the core of it and the heart of it is really mundane if you're from any other industry, but absolutely game changing if you're in our little world in in insurance broking. And that is producing platform. So the actual broking processes, the same as what applied systems do, and we have these other ones called actuaries and SSP, but doing it properly. And the key thing is to have all of the risk data in the platform. So the prevailing way, the typical way of so so so most you gotta understand a little bit about the history of broking software.
So most broking software emerged from basically transaction accounting systems. So the key thing in the nineteen eighties so we we've got we've got these four platforms, as I say, in The UK. There's applied to bringing the epic system across from The US, which is marginal improvement on some of the existing ones, but then they've got a whole a whole challenge of of of de Americanizing it as they bring it across. But the you know, it's not just dollars to pound signs. It's other stuff. So so the basically, there's two things that that that the traditional broking software has done.
One is it's focused in on the transaction, and it's it's basically focused on getting the commission calculation correct between the broker and the and the insurer and logging that there was a transaction and use various regulated client money calculations you need to do. Complexity there, and it's valid, and that's a good thing to do. And the computers are well organized to do it, and they've been doing it since the 1970s and 80s. And that's what but but because they started there, what they did is they built all the process functionality and and more importantly, the product and risk information logging functionality from that core thing, which is I need to get the right transaction.
So they started in the middle and then built their way out. So what typically happens in most brokerage or all all these brokerage systems is that they they've got a hodgepodge of data. They've definitely got the the core data you need to be able to do the calculation about your commission and how much premiums written and so on. So that will be relatively robust data. But what they won't have is the data that is really important to make the underwriting decision. Most of that is not found within these systems.
Most of it is found in, as you said it before, in PDFs that are sitting there separately or Word documents that are created as reports for the clients or Excel spreadsheets or whatever. And there may be a subset of data or there'll be there'll be some fields which are kind of never used that could be used, but they're not quite right. So they basically broken and this is one of the one of the starting reasons why we built our own platform was we thought the data model for commercial insurance is is not fit for it does not include it does not allow you to put the core risk data into it.
So what happens is that the there are four to five levels of rekey, etcetera. So the very foundational step is to have a data model. And there's a there's a key process in Broken called the fact find, which is when you actually go and write down what you find in a in a in your in this client that you know, you go around their factory and you write down, you know, how many people are working there, what's the wage role of that, what's the type of construction of the building, what are the business activities, what machines are they using to do that activity, what would happen if one of them exploded, you know, all this kind of stuff.
And it's quite complex. And it's and the really interesting thing about commercial insurance as opposed to personal insurance is that's really heterogeneous data. So there's a massive variety of data. There's so many configurations of it. So to have a good data model at the heart of what you do is not is nontrivial exercise, and that's why most people have shied away from it. So the response that most people in the industry, both insurers and brokers have done, is what they've done is they defaulted to the product structure as their data model and then only put a subset of that data into any systems because most of it, as I say, the real value adding stuff that enables an underwriter to make the decision was sitting outside of the system.
So they had a product structure, a product oriented data structure that was non comprehensive. And so that's what the norm has been. And what that means is that there's massive inefficiency in being able to just transact insurance broking because of the rekey issue. What it also means is that there's there's no usable data inside broking systems. The only usable data is that that the the insurers later in the process have consolidated themselves and they only use you know, insurers will send them these great big beautiful, you know, PhD thesis kind of levels of insight into these risks and the insurers are throwing away 90% of it and just capturing a few key numbers that they need to do their rating and making a few qualitative judgments on some other stuff.
And so you've got all this complete lack of this data and information in the system. So that's the foundation step and that's what enables everything else. If you've got all the relevant data and then you grow that data over time and you augment it with third party insights and so on, then that for us is the foundation stone. And that still for us is quite a big differentiator versus everyone else in the market. So that's our sort of starting point. And then everything else we want to do builds on that.
Are you capturing and storing loss run data? I mean, what are we talking about here? Yeah. Some of it's loss run data, but the you know, the to to the extent that the client knows that. So it's, you know, it's log of all their claims that they've had that they're aware of. Yes. That's a key thing. It's their business process. It's specifics construction of their premises, etcetera, etcetera. So it's all the things that a broker is already asking, you know, that's and then, you know, adding insights to that from, you know, like so there's quite good there's quite a good open data set available in The UK and most European countries.
And I think most places in The US, you know, you can see the crime statistics. You can see the the use of adjacent premises. You can see how far it is from the fire station. You know, you can see the flood zones that the government have articulated and then some insurers use different flood mapping. So you've got all these kind of layers of different hazards and so on that you can layer on to this data. But the core of it is always insights about what this business does.
You know, what am I doing? I'm a printer. I've got a great big machine. If this machine goes bust, then I can't do any printing. How much will it cost me to get another machine? And, well, actually, it takes a year to get the spare part from Germany. Oh, goodness. Okay. So that's gonna be a big claim if that goes wrong, etcetera. So you've got all these, you know, all these these layers of information build, that's what a broker does. They go in and they find all this stuff out.
But then what a typical broker does, they write it in a Word document, fire it off in a PDF to or they get or as you say, they get the client to write in a Word document or a PDF. They fired off the underwriter, and and they don't care about that information, neither does the underwriter. The underwriter reads it once and goes, yeah. 10,000 or, you know, £10,000, £20,000. But the no one's actually retained that information in any meaningful way. And so that's a that's a big issue.
Are you structuring that? Yeah. No. We're we're structuring it, and we are then and the key thing, and then the efficiency part is we're then massively reusing that. So the big efficiency in our system comes when you come around to do a renewal. So when you come to do a renewal for us, there's a there's a key thing that in that the brokers have to do. They have to prep the documents for the next renewal. So you you wrote this piece of business January or February.
You're you're, okay. That's great. We did all that. There was a lot of the well, that was really hard work to do all that structuring of the information, writing those beautiful reports, getting consolidating all the pictures, you know, la di da di da, copy pasting Google Maps and all that stuff. Oh, I did this lovely beautiful Word document. Okay. Great. Oh, now I've got to do it all again for this year because, yes, I can work a little bit from last year, but actually, you know, none of it's in the system and and and it's and all these changes have happened in the year, and I need to consolidate those.
And, oh my goodness. So you typically go a big risk or largest risk sale on paying, I don't know, $3,050,000 dollars or pounds would be, you know, two days work for someone to prep, then you go and see the client update it, etcetera. For us, it's a ten minute job. Yeah. Sure. Because because you've kept that up to date all the year, and it's it's a it's a it's a structured dataset and a dynamic dataset that can
James Benhamknow, that's always up to date. So what we're seeing here is a continued trend that we've seen and we've been talking about on the podcast for the last 10 episodes, and that is there are certainly technologists that are building products for traditional firms to implement to try and digitize those firms. And then there's others that are saying,
John Warburtonto heck with that. I'm gonna go and start my own insurance firm. So Yeah. Yeah. You could have gotten together and said, I'm gonna compete against Epic. Applied Systems. Yeah. We could have done. Yeah. You can say, I'm gonna build a new Epic, I'm gonna sell it to all the the broking companies out there. Actually, we have done that. What what the and maybe it would have been an easier road because it's not been smooth, obviously, and we're still smaller than perhaps it would have been if we'd done that.
On the other side, my problem is I love insurance brokers. I think insurance brokers are really cool as individuals. The people who do the broking that is, the actual, you know, the producers themselves, the guys who go out there, bloody heroes. They go into these industrial estates. They they're people in suits and and and on shoes, they go in and they and they and they understand what a what a a paper warehouse does or a or a or a metal, you know, manufacturing business. And then they're in an accountant's office the following week, and they're advising them about professional indemnity.
These are these are, you know, the real, like, deep insight business consulting skill set. It's really fantastic. And then, you know, they've got twenty years of of of apprenticeship learning and all that. Fantastic people. Their bosses, however, utter idiots. So so so I'm like, do I really want to go around and spend the the the the latter half of my career going and selling to a bunch of idiots, or do I want to actually hang out with the cool people who are the ones who actually do the job and make their lives better?
And that that was kind of why we ended up doing what we're doing, which is to say we can be a better broking firm. Yeah. Okay. It's a slightly harder road, but actually and also from an economic point of view, to be honest, the margins are with being a broker, really selling the technology to them. So, you know, if you sold it to everybody, I guess there's a margin in that. But, you know, their buying cycles would be painful. You know, it's just not much fun.
So from our point of view, it wasn't about being a technology provider to brokerages, it was about actually being a brokerage but being a sort of full stack brokerage, you know, same sort of I mean, putting myself in a slightly grand company in terms of money raising ability, but, you know, the same sort of insights as a lemonade would have had. You know, we're not going to go and buy whatever the prevailing bit of technology is. We're to build our own, but we're going to be in the industry, be a distributor in the industry ourselves.
Sure. And you're not gonna sell your tech to other people. It's only available for your company. Yeah. I mean, having said all of that, there is a there is a a very friendly firm of ours. So we we did decide to build our tech first. We we we read the lean startup and all the other stuff that you read, and then we we ignored half of it because just we're bloody minded middle aged men. So so we built our our core platform, and we did that with an existing broking firm, which is very helpful, actually.
You know, if you're gonna do lean startup type approaches and MVPs and so on, you if you've got people you can work with, guinea pig users and so on, that's obviously far superior. So we implemented back in 2017 before we'd really got going as a broker, you need to be regulated as a broker. It takes six to eight months anyway. So back in 2017, we launched our platform with a team of 10 people in an existing broking firm just to basically smooth off the rough edges.
We probably didn't do them as good service for the first six months of that because it really was rough around the edges. But they just used our platform exclusively. They put a load of business through it. We then learned and iterated and so on. And so by the time we sort of started trading in earnest about eighteen months ago, you know, well, firstly, these guys who've been using it, they they expanded. It's now 20 odd guys that they've got using it. And and then we they put through, you know, I don't know, $1,520,000,000 of of premium through it, which is pretty good for us.
It was a good starting point. And then when we had our own brokers, they we we knew we had something that was a lot more robust. So, yeah, it was so we definitely work with you know, we work with an existing firm, but it's not our a real idea to go and, you know No. But you had to build a sales pipeline. Yeah. You had to have a beta client. It's it's hard to it's hard to build for an idea. It's much easier to build for a company, just in general.
Yeah. Yeah. Well, you know, otherwise, we didn't need you to recruit brokers, what would they have done? You know? They oh, here's a platform that's not quite ready yet, but I've got some clients I want to write. And if we were holding the regulatory risk of noncompliance as well as the sort of technology vendor risk, it's a bit too much. But, no, that was a really nice way to get over this initial Yeah. Initial kind of MVP problem. And then
James Benhamwe've we've ramped up our own our own brokers since then. Now one of the things I've seen brokerages that are really tech centered brokerages do reasonably well is take all the structured data on their clients, and then they bring it into a common form for each of the markets they're shopping. They either format it in the PDF, Lord help us, that market is asking for, or they get even more sophisticated than that. Can you talk to me about because that's a big part of this, is normalizing the data input, normalizing the storage, putting it in some kind of structured format, having a way of dealing with unstructured data like photos, videos, and free text narratives, but then putting that in a way that each market because each market has a specific application that you've gotta modify your data for.
Right? Yeah. That's that's right. It's not quite as prevalent in The UK as it is in The US. The the
John Warburtonwhat we don't have as well is we have one regulated market, where you've got 50, which is a real pain Ain't it fantastic? I know. It's like you you kinda take all the economies of scale and then rip them out again by having 50 different jurisdictions on stuff like insurance. Doesn't really make sense.
James BenhamThe Actually, let's pause there. I've spent a lot of time thinking about a federalist system versus a group collection of states. And the interesting thing that it's driven in America has been an intense amount of competition between states for businesses and for regulatory infrastructure. Because it's so easy to move states, it's so hard to move countries, right? Yeah. You can get an entirely different set of laws, taxes, and infrastructure by moving states. And so you end up with a highly competitive system here, where Texas is constantly competing against California and New York, and Illinois is constantly competing against Wisconsin and Indiana,
John Warburtonand they're competing on tax rates and infrastructure and regulatory rates. I mean, it's really fascinating. I guess, you know, maybe old fashioned, but I think it's about what I mean, the tax rate thing I totally get because, obviously, you've got a lot more local taxes than we have. We have everything if they, you know, call it federal level, you like, the national level. But apart from business rates, which are property tax, but it's insurance regulator issues. Oh, yeah. I know. My understanding is if you're a brokerage, you've just got to fill in a load more forms.
You do. Do. Do. And it's just a bit of a pain in the bum. Yeah. And then and then as a carrier, you've got to then submit your so if you're a big carrier, no problem at all. You'll you'll you'll file in 50 states for your workers' comp policy or whatever, but obviously there's quite big there's quite big differences in, like, know, California will have a particular type of workers' comp that they need specification and some people will not be in that market in charge. Yeah.
I I I that's the I mean, we you know, at some point, we will think about coming to The US, and certainly the initial research I've done suggests that you pick a you could pick a couple of benign states to start with and and try and build from their assembly business. When they came over, they they they started in Massachusetts, I think, and then and one other, and and, you know, you just need somewhere as a base, and then you can work out all this regulatory.
Target an economy bigger than Great Britain's. Come to Texas, buddy. Let's do it. Let's go. Yeah. Only if it only if it can be in in Austin, though. Oh, you're killing me. You're killing me. Not not Aggie. Not Aggieland. Yeah. So let's let's talk about the future.
James BenhamCustomized output around significantly minimizing the amount of rework and manual reentry that your producers have to do, and also making it really a producer centric business model internally and a client centric business model externally and making it much less about the firm. Yep. That mentality, that methodology dovetails with a movement, a organizational model called Teal that you guys ascribe to. Briefly tell listeners out there what Teal is all about. Yeah. So this is a
John Warburtonthere's a there's a there's a number of publications on this. Think there's a thing called holocracy and as well as others. But the one that I found compelling was a book by a Belgian guy, and normally, we don't in Britain, we don't like things by Belgian people. We think it's about the most boring country on God's earth. Except for Tintin. Except for Tintin. Tintin's not bad, and Jean Claude Van Damme, maybe. There you go. And the chocolate. And the waffles. Make eight chocolates. And the waffles.
Yeah. The no. I think they're more of the Dutch, actually. The stroopwafel. True. Yeah. Okay. I'll I'll I'll get that too. For Belgium. Okay. So this guy this guy If you ask a Brit what's name some famous things from Belgium, they they mention a fictional character from from by Agatha Christie called Hercule Poirot. Oh. And that's all they ever come up Sorry. He doesn't exist. So Hercule Poirot
James Benhamdoes exist in many people's head, my friend. And I watched Indeed. Indeed. But he's the most famous. I watched every single episode of Boi Ro, so
John Warburtonlet's not let's not leave that one out. Despite all of that, this guy, Frederic Laloux, his name is, pretty cool guy, he wrote this book called Reinventing Organizations. And and what's really interesting is that he it's it's a different way of looking at the world and and the history of the world. And and and basically saying, actually, if you look at world history through the lens of organizational structures, you can go there's there's, like, you know, the caveman thing, and they call that the red world, and this is basically, like, you know, a kind of somewhat capricious autocrat type thing, but at least there but but there was an innovation there that was about it was about top down control, and then you went to bureaucracies.
They call it the I think it's the not Amber, what's it called? Brown sort of thing, and that was like the church, know, like armies, where it's division of labor and so on, hierarchy, and you do what you're told, but you do up through a hierarchy, and there's some objective standards. And then you've got this sort of strive for innovation, the modern corporation, but let's say the sort of, you know, Mad Men style, General Motors, Ford Motor Company, 1960s, multinational, maybe into the 90s, you know, the way the sort of, you know, you burnout and all that sort of thing, but it introduces some innovation and so on.
And then you've got the green type of organization. This is sort of reaction to the sort of corporate thing, and you still see this, you know, Ben and Jerry's ice cream and those sorts of people, it kind of gets a bit mashed up with a certain political sensibility or a certain sort of, you know, world view, which is, you know, a particular ideology. And it was the but they introduced this idea of stakeholder management and all this sort of thing, But it got a bit discredited because, you know, it's a bit directionless and and it can can seem a little bit up its own backside.
And so this teal thing is a sort of next evolution in this theory, which says, actually, there's some good in that whole there all these previous iterations of, like, what the state of the art in organizations is has had merit, and you need to build on that. But, actually, all of them left a lot of value on the table. The core real value was that the creativity and the energy of the people who work in these organizations was a kind of not really being optimized, not really being being pushed.
So they talk about this. This guy talks about there being three imperatives. They said the first one is evolutionary purpose, which is that what you your organization stands for something positive in the world, and and, you know, it's a big thing. We'll talk about it in the context of insurance breaking, but my view is there's a massive noble purpose to insurance brokerage. It's just people don't really you know, if you watch Groundhog Day, perhaps you don't. That's you know, that he's not the best advocate for insurance brokers, that guy in Groundhog Day.
You know? Ned? And then Ned Ryerson? Ned Ryerson. Exactly. He's not the he's not the best, you know, because it's all about the selling. It's not about the the the protecting So so that you just named literally my number one favorite movie of all time that I watch every year on Groundhog Day, which happened to be Sunday, and I wear my Groundhog Day Punk Chitani filled T shirt while I watch it. So that is yeah. Now It is. He's not the best representation for sure. He's not.
He's not. And it's not just his coat. It's it's the whole thing. And then and then wholeness is a second part, which is that when you come to work, you bring your whole self, what's in all? You know? You don't you don't park your Brexit or your Donald Trump opinions actually at the door completely, but you've got to be respectful, obviously, and you've got to get on. But, you know, you you bring your whole self, and then and then and then others support you, you know, accept you for who you are as well, and and you you find a kind of way of working together, which which which feels congruent with who you are.
And then you self management is the third one, and self management is basically saying, look. I'm here. It's it's an adult to adult thing. I'm not waiting for my boss to to find out that I haven't done any work. I'm gonna get kind of get organized and and and drive things to my agenda. And if you've got those three things, evolutionary purpose, I. E. The organization feels like it's doing the right thing according to your values, wholeness, which is that I bring my whole self to work, and self management.
Then if you do that, if you get those things right, and it's quite a lot of serendipity to get that right, it doesn't mean that there's an absence of process and structure. It's not like a kindergarten thing where everyone's just sitting around outside a teepee and kind of singing kumbaya or whatever. It's real. You've got to focus on what the organization's about. If you get those things right, you can unlock massive amounts of creativity and productivity. And so my insight was, if I think of going back to my career and I think back to, you know, all those problems of this kind of very robber baron type of approach with consolidation insurance broking that I saw back in the naughties, I saw how technology could actually be used to support the processes and the way that people are working.
But if you overlay that onto insurance broking, it looks like it fits really well because the interesting thing about insurance broking is that it is fundamentally done by people in relatively small cells, one or two people organ you know, client facing units. And there's not there's not a massive leverage of, let's say, a massive brand or or something capabilities, which are, say, industrial capabilities. This is an artisan job. You're you're going and you're you're creating this value when you go and see your client, what you need is just really good tools to do it with and a really good proposition and everything else.
And you need to feel that you're supported and you need to feel that you're doing the right thing and that you're you're you're, you know, you've got the flexible way of working and all the rest of it. So so we anyway, so we've we've sort of evolved this this approach into insurance broking. We when we do our inductions, we we take sort of six to eight people on at a time. When we do our inductions, we spend a whole day just talking about culture, talking about what's the right thing.
And if you talk to anyone in my organization, you say, what's Teal? They'll tell you what I just told you, and they'll say, yeah. We're a Teal organization. We really buy this. But we're not talking about a bunch of, you know, nerds who are all millennial, self referential, you know, people sitting around in a bubble. This is not who my staff are. My I've got people from late twenties. I've got the oldest is 61. I've got people from different national backgrounds. I've got someone from Nigeria, someone from Japan, someone from Sri Lanka.
I've got people who are from the grittiest, you know, most sort of, let's say I'm just trying to find a nice word for it in your world. Let's say, what we would say sort of working class or, you know, like, gritty gritty industrial, post industrial Sure. Backgrounds, and, you know, and there were things in between, and and and people who've, you know, done it for thirty years and then studied and so on. But but the the point is this is not this is a glue which can work for anyone as long as what you know, this is about being that authentic insurance broker that you can be, not about fitting to a template that's set by a bunch of people who like avocado on toast and sipping lattes in a coastal city in The US.
Yep.
James BenhamI don't know what you're talking about. No. I do know. I I do you would also feel comfortable if you loved avocado on toast and you like lattes and etcetera. I don't like lattes. I don't do caffeine, but I do love a good avocado on toast, but I've liked that for twenty years. So to be to be But you were you were an early adopter. To to be clear, I lived in Mexico in the mid nineties and fell in love with the avocado about
John Warburtonabout twenty five years ago. Well, it's a bit more having avocado where you live is a bit more authentic than doing it in the middle of London in Shoreditch Yeah. Wearing your wearing your skinny jeans with Oh, I know. With your beard? With your with your soul patch and so on. Don't forget about the oiled beard. Yeah. Exactly. I went into Browns. Ain't that Browns Hotel? It's near Westminster.
James BenhamYeah. Yeah. Yep. And I went into Browns because one of my friends used to always love going to Browns every time I went to London. So went there and had tea, and number one thing on the menu, avocado toast. And I'm like, that that is not British, but it is but it is here. Well, look, this has been a really interesting conversation. I'm excited about what you guys are up to. I appreciate you spending an hour with us and talking about technology and process and people.
I mean, you're you're really trying to tackle a big issue, and that is what's wrong with brokerage and do it by pushing on a few different levers. Right? People, process, and technology all simultaneously, and not just building a service company for brokers, but actually building a modern brokerage.
John WarburtonYep. So how how do people find out more information about your firm and what you're doing? Well, our website, to be honest, is a bit crappy. It's one of those things that, you know, you never quite get around to making your website up to date, do you? So it's a bit a bit outdoor. So so have a have a look on there. Obviously, if you are listening to this in The UK and you're a broker, probably unlikely as you're probably not an industry watcher. But if you are, then get in touch with we are hiring.
And we're hiring if you're wherever you're based in The UK, we're hiring. We are definitely going to look at probably within Europe, the next step post Brexit. We probably need to go and set up in Ireland or Germany or somewhere first, and then we would we'd build out from there. But, yeah, if you want to talk to us about I mean, I think what we're really interested in doing is having dialogue with people who've I mean, even people who've got, you know, traditional brokerage and and and are really pushing the envelope on how to run a broken culture and and and the insights around that.
That that, I think, is really interesting. And I I'm on the the the council of a thing called Insurtech UK, so it's it's about sixty, seventy companies in The UK that are getting together to sort of be connecting the Insurtechs together. There's only a few of us that are doing commercial lines, that are doing commercial insurance in that space, but we would love to connect with US organizations that are doing similar things. And, yeah, definitely just drop me a line. I'm on LinkedIn, and and we can we can have a dialogue.
Awesome. And that's Konsileo. That's konsileo.com. You heard it here. He may come to That's right. Mainland Europe, and then if he really wises up, he'll come to Texas. Well, I always like coming to I always like coming to The States if I need to Yeah. If need to buy if I need to buy good shirts. And better avocados because we do have And better. You do have really good avocados. Well,
James Benhamit's been a real pleasure speaking with you. I appreciate your time today, and thanks for joining us on the InsurTech Geek podcast, John. Thanks, James. All the best. Awesome. And that is our discussion. This has been the InsurTech Geek podcast powered by JBKnowledge, JBKnowledge dot com. It's all about technology that's transforming and disrupting the insurance world. I've been your host, James Benham. My website is jamesbenham.com. Big thanks to, big daddy Jim Greenlee, our podcast producer, Cara Daltonaro, our creative producer, and thank you for joining us today.
I look forward to talking to y'all soon. We're taking you on a journey through insurance tech, so enjoy the ride and keep geeking out.

