Skip to content
The InsurTech Geek PodcastEpisodesTopicsGuestsBooksAboutSponsorContactSubscribe
Jay Vinda
← Episode guide Episode 185

How Would I Hack Mosaic? Jay Vinda on Cyber Risk Engineering, the Criminal Marketplace, and Why the Basics Still Win

Jay Vinda
Global CISO & Cyber Risk Engineering Lead · Mosaic Insurance
Published Oct 9, 2026
Runtime 34 minutes
Host James Benham
YouTube Spotify Amazon iHeart Apple

Jay Vinda

Jay Vinda, Global CISO and Cyber Risk Engineering Lead at Mosaic Insurance, joins James Benham live at ITC 2026 to explain why the person who buys a cyber policy is rarely the person who knows what could go wrong, how criminal marketplaces made funding the only real barrier to cybercrime, why generative AI erased the old phishing tells, and what frontier AI changes for attackers and defenders.

Watch here

The full episode

Press play for the whole conversation.

Sponsored by
Terra
1

From Chef to Engineer to CISO

Jay was born and raised in London, and growing up he wanted to be a chef. He still loves to cook, although delivery has mostly won. At university he studied mechanical engineering for four years, a stretch that included a couple of months in Peru building wind turbines for villages with no access to electricity. What engineering really gave him, he says, was a love of solving problems and the habit of looking at anything and asking how you would start.

Out of university he could not find a job, so he applied for almost everything. A cybersecurity graduate scheme said yes, and the plan was to do it for a couple of years and then switch back to engineering. He started in 2016, at what he calls a real inflection point: the Mirai botnet was turning swarms of connected devices into denial of service weapons, and 2017 brought ransomware like WannaCry and espionage campaigns backed by nation states. He liked it, and he stayed. Along the way he went back to university while working and earned a master's in information security, a decision that felt like a great idea right up until the dissertation.

The job changed under him. In the early days cyber was the kind of work where you built drones and hacked them because it was fun. Within a couple of years it had become a board issue, with regulatory compliance and cyber risk management turning into disciplines of their own. Done really badly at a company, he says, security failures could cost lives, or bring massive fines.

"Now I've got a job that actually means something, that actually really needs to be thought about."

Jay Vinda
2

The Honeypot of Honeypots

James calls cybersecurity one of the most important technical professions in insurance right now, and the reason is simple. Insurers sit on a treasure trove of personal data, everything you would ever need to hack the world. Jay's frustration is that the industry does not get much value out of it either. There is a treasure trove of data in insurance, he says, but the way it has been standardized, collated and categorized is just not that great.

Most of Jay's career before insurance was spent with financial institutions, mostly banks, and with government. After about eight years he wanted a change of pace and scenery, and insurance looked like a friendlier place to try. Mosaic is a specialist insurer with regional hubs across six countries and two Lloyd's syndicates it underwrites on behalf of. Jay describes it as close to the MGA model, except Mosaic has skin in the game: it always keeps a minimum of 20 to 25 percent of every risk on its own paper. It writes around ten lines, from cyber and political violence to environmental and professional liability. The name, they agree, is appropriate.

"Insurers have loads of data, but they're just not using it very well."

Jay Vinda
3

Two Hats, Two Reporting Lines

Jay's role is unusual. As CISO he reports to Mosaic's chief operating officer, who leads operational resilience for the organization, and he owns cyber resilience. He also reports to the head of cyber underwriting, a team of about 40 underwriters spread across Canada, the US, Bermuda, the UK, Germany and Dubai. For them, he uses his security knowledge to improve how each individual risk is assessed, and uses threat intelligence to map out the scenarios that make up the portfolio. In effect, he does for Mosaic's insureds what he does for Mosaic.

He also partners directly with insureds to help shape their security strategy. Some have their own CISO; others give the title to whoever runs IT. Mosaic has traditionally focused on mid-market and large corporate clients with revenues of 150 million dollars and up, and this year it opened an SME platform for companies in the 10 to 150 million dollar range. Those businesses usually do not have a CISO at all, and they often outsource to managed service providers without anyone in house who can challenge them on what their risk profile really looks like.

4

The CISO and the Buyer Are Not in the Same Room

At ITC, Jay is speaking about cyber risk through the eyes of a CISO, and it is the topic he is most passionate about right now. When a company buys cyber insurance, the buyer tends to be the risk manager, someone in the CRO's or CFO's office, or the chief legal officer. Their motivation is to get the most coverage at the lowest premium, and that is the conversation they have with the broker.

But before anyone shops for a policy, someone with a security mindset has already decided there is cyber risk the company needs to transfer: the things that genuinely keep them up at night, the problems they are struggling to solve.

Part of Jay's job is to bring those two together, so the risk manager understands that the policy wording and endorsements need to cover the scenarios that could materially go wrong for the organization. James asks whether that makes him part therapist. Jay laughs that at CISO conferences they already call it CISO therapy.

"Right now you've got a real big disconnect between the person who knows what could really go wrong and the person who's buying insurance coverage."

Jay Vinda
5

A Criminal Marketplace That Runs Like a Business

James has been building software since the internet commercialized in the early nineties, and was on bulletin board systems before that. There have always been threats, he says, mostly malicious viruses. What is different now is that the threat is state sponsored, well funded, well organized, and run a lot like an insurance company. Jay goes further: it is literally a criminal marketplace.

In the past, an attacker needed both the technical capability to operate an attack and the commercial mindset to monetize it. Neither is required anymore. With funding, a criminal can go to the marketplace and assemble the capabilities they need, and ransomware operators will take care of the monetizing.

The shift, Jay says, is not so much in capability as in capacity: how many people can now become cybercriminals. James adds that they need fewer people, too, running open weight models on their own machines with no guardrails. Their emails, text messages and synthetic voice work are all getting better.

"Really, you don't need that much to be a criminal."

Jay Vinda
6

The Tells Are Gone

Jay shares an example from the Asia Pacific region. People in Japan used to spot phishing by how the characters were put together, because an attacker who did not speak Japanese produced text that read as broken to a native speaker. Generative AI made it easy to write Japanese, Chinese or Korean that looks like a native speaker wrote it, and that way of spotting phishing stopped working.

The same is happening in English. It used to be easy to sniff out a scam: the formatting was wrong, the images were off, the HTML was poorly formed, and there was always a sense of urgency. Today, Jay says, the opening message often has no urgency and no link. It might be an email that looks like it was meant for someone else. You reply to correct the sender, they apologize, and since you are chatting anyway, the conversation carries on. And it works.

James recalls his cousin, a comedian, who about 20 years ago texted thousands of numbers by hand with a simple "hey, what's up" and was amazed by how many strangers engaged in long conversations.

7

"That's My Fault"

That raises an uncomfortable point about security awareness training. The industry spends a lot of time teaching people what bad looks like, and Jay worries it has become a liability shift: if you trained your users, the click is their fault. He does not see it that way.

A single link should not be able to take a company down, and building that resilience is the job. Jay describes the fun part of it simply: his job is basically sitting there thinking how he would hack Mosaic, how he would impact its customers, and then how he would stop it.

Synthetic voice attacks are an obvious next test. Jay has not run one at Mosaic yet, and both agree it is not hard. Open source tools make it simple, and the source material is everywhere: people speak at conferences that get published online, and company marketing teams post clips on Instagram and TikTok. Legitimate voice and video providers make you verify that you are who you say you are. Plenty of other tools do not.

"If Mosaic gets taken down because someone clicked on a dodgy link, that's my fault."

Jay Vinda
8

The Basics Still Win

Asked what keeps him up at night, Jay's answer is not exotic. It is the basics, for two reasons. First, many of the controls that protect an organization are process based. They do not need a big technology spend, but they need a lot of effort to get a control to the point where it actually prevents a threat. The temptation is to skip the effort and buy a tool.

Data classification and data loss prevention are his example. Organizations keep trying to hand the classification problem to someone else, and it becomes very expensive without being solved. Put in the time and effort yourself, he argues, and you can solve it fairly quickly.

Second, the goalposts keep moving. The basics used to be a strong password and antivirus. Then came multifactor authentication, prompts that went from once a month to once a day, and now passwordless sign in, passkeys and biometrics. James notes that authentication barely changed for decades and then transformed in the last two years. Jay welcomes it: a password manager is a vulnerability in itself, and biometrics and passkeys make his life a lot easier.

"There's so many tools out there that say they're AI-powered cybersecurity or next-generation AI cybersecurity, and it's just a lot of fluff."

Jay Vinda
9

Frontier AI, 26-Year-Old Vulnerabilities, and the Risk Appetite Gap

On the positive side, both are most excited about frontier AI, though Jay looks past the hype. For a cybercriminal, he says, it is not really a game changer yet.

It works and it is cheap, so why switch to something a lot more expensive? The defensive case is different: frontier AI can detect zero-day vulnerabilities before they are used. Jay points to Mythos finding vulnerabilities that were 26 years old, and takes two lessons from it. The reviews in use today, code reviews, human reviews and security tests, did not catch them, so this is a real step change. And he does not believe nobody knew about them for 26 years. More likely, someone knew and was saving the zero-day for a better opportunity. Now defenders can find those holes and fix them before they are used against them.

James's own biggest worry is simpler: people doing stupid things, or, as they settle on, naive and trusting things. He has two or three friends who fell for the gift card scam, and one lost their job over it. But he is just as excited about the defensive side. He vibe coded his own site, jamesbenham.com, had an AI model run a full penetration test on it, pushed it to dig ten levels deeper at maximum effort, and got back 27 upgrades. The criminals have these tools, he says, and so do we.

Jay notes that AI in security operations is not new; it was already being built in when he started in 2016. What holds defenders back is appetite for risk.

If a criminal's AI experiment fails, they move on and do something else. If a defender lets AI make decisions autonomously and it goes wrong, it hurts a lot. The landscape is now so asymmetrical in the attackers' favor that defenders are almost forced to try, helped by models they can explain and understand much better than before. The one thing that still annoys Jay: the models are massive people pleasers. These days he ends his prompts by asking for an honest opinion.

"Social engineering is still a very easy way to compromise a company."

Jay Vinda

"Our risk appetite on the defensive side is just a lot lower than a criminal's."

Jay Vinda
10

Key Takeaways

1
Crime no longer needs skill: Criminal marketplaces and ransomware operators mean attackers need funding, not technical ability, to launch an attack.
2
AI erased the easy tells: Generative AI writes flawless phishing in any language, so bad grammar and urgency no longer give it away.
3
Basics beat shiny tools: Strong controls take effort, not big spend. Many tools sold as AI-powered security never fix the problem you actually have.
4
Connect the CISO and the buyer: The person who knows what could go wrong rarely buys the cyber policy, so coverage often misses the real scenarios.
11

Connect with Jay Vinda

Jay Vinda Mosaic Insurance Podcast

The full transcript

▸ Read it · 6,496 words

Transcribed automatically from the episode audio, so some names and terms may be misheard.

James BenhamAnd we are here with Jay here live in Las Vegas, Viva Las Vegas, or not so much depending on how you feel about Vegas with my good friend from London, Jay Vinda, the CISO, that's chief information security officer at Mosaic Insurance. Jay, how are doing? Doing alright, man. Doing pretty good. Still jet lagged, but first time in Vegas. Yeah. First time in Vegas. Yeah. Yeah. There's there's a lot of fun to be had here. There's

Jay Vindaa lot of exhaustion to be had here too, though. Yeah. But, you know, you keep auction pumped into casinos, you don't really feel it, so that's nice. Yep. That and cigarette smoke. Yeah. I have noticed, actually. Quite quite fun. They they they they let you smoke at the table, so you don't Anywhere. Yeah. They don't want you leaving. They don't want you leaving because they know as soon as you leaving, you have that kind of thought. You're like, what the fuck? Should I leave? Yeah. Maybe I should go to bed.

Yeah. And they're like, maybe you Stay

James Benhamhere. Stay here. Smoke here. Do whatever you like here. You wanna go to a show? It's right there, and then you can come back here after the show. Right. Yeah. Exactly. It's... It is a... Stay building. They... You know, we talk a lot about software companies hacking human attention span and, you know, forcing people into doom scrolling. Yeah. But the original attention span hackers Oh, it's all here. You're here, buddy. Hey. Just go check out a slot machine. I honestly... The amount of, like, the dopamine hits just from walking through them, like...

It's all dopamine hits. Yeah. The... Even down to the tones they use. Exactly. Yeah. The frequency of the tones, the volume level. Yeah.

Jay VindaIt's really well thought out. Mean Oh, wow. Honestly, that's one way of saying... I mean, just sitting here and being like, wonder how much revenue cost per minute. Like, it's I mean, being really well thought out would imply that

James Benhamthey were... Had the best interests of their guests at all. I agree. You know, it's a profitable... It's a profit making company. Right?

Jay VindaAbsolutely.

James BenhamIt is. So this is your first time in Vegas Mhmm. Which means it's your first time at ITC It is. Because it's always in Vegas. Yep. You... You've been in insurance for two years. You've been in cybersecurity for ten. Yep. But I wanna go back back in the time, way back in the time. Now I am a a bit of a aficionado for accents. Okay. And so it sounds to me like you grew up in London. I did. Yeah. Well So so that that... That's the...

I'm just gonna guess. So born and raised in London. You still live in London and work in London. You've never been to Vegas, which means you haven't spent much time in America because you would've you would've come to Vegas if it was a conference. Yeah. But you you definitely

Jay Vindahad a career before insurance. Yep. And and it sounds like you had a career before cyber. So walk me back to when you were a kid, when you're growing up in in England. Yep. First off, what's your favorite football team? Sure. Not not a big fan of football. I... You know, cricket? I started enjoying, like, Manchester City was good fun for me and growing up Liverpool as well. But the the thing the thing that I really get annoyed about with football fans is you having a great conversation about the current season, and then someone just pulls out shit that happened in 1990.

Yeah. Like, honestly, I don't I don't know. That's a British thing, though. That's it is. That

James Benhamis... But that applies beyond football. No. You you you talk you talk about current year politics. You're like, yeah. But Maggie Thatcher in 1992.

Jay VindaYou remember? Yeah. It's just too much, honestly. And so I just gave up on it after that. Okay. So do you like cricket? Do you like rugby? Do you like... What do you like? I like rugby. I like football a bit. I like watching football. I just don't keep up to date as much Got it. That's fine. As other people. But no, like, growing up, always kind of been, you know, sports is always around. So what what'd you wanna do when you're growing up? Oh, when I was growing up, I wanted to be a chef.

A chef? Yeah. Did... Yeah. Do you still like to cook? Not as much. No. Delivery is just so, you know, convenient now. And I think the issue for me was, you know, I love cooking. It's a really good thing to me just to relax and better switch off or to it. But I get really bored of cooking the same meals all the time and then just eating that the whole time. Whereas delivery,

James Benhamget whatever you get whatever you fancy. Right? Well, you you know what's been a great hack? Because I grew up cooking. My mother is an incredible... I grew up in South Of Louisiana, which is, you know, the France of America. Yeah. Right? We're like the Quebec of The United States. So strong French heritage. My mother's French. Okay. Like, not from France. French heritage. Oh, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. And her mother only... Her mother spoke French and English and cooked French food at home. My mother kinda did the same thing with me, but I I can tell you, I love cooking.

Claude has been my godsend because it keeps track of, you know, what I'm eating, and I have food log in it. And then I just say, hey. Look. What what should I make tonight? Yeah. And and I'll take pictures of my fridge and my pantry, and it automatically recipe. It automatically inventories what I have, and then it gives me ideas. That's pretty solid. And... Because I really I really love to... I really do love to cook, and, you know, it helps if you have someone to cook for because it's more fun to cook for two than for one.

I see. Yeah. For me, I'm cooking for one, I'm just like, well, so I've got this, and then I'm gonna have this Yeah. For lunch and for dinner, and I'm just like That means invite some friends over. Right? And then I and I I generally rotate between fish, pork, chicken, beef, but that's not what this podcast is about. You wanted to be a chef. That didn't happen. You went to Uni for what? Went to Uni for mechanical engineering there. So I spent four years on that.

Jay VindaReally enjoyed that, actually. I kind of... I didn't really know why I wanted to be kind of growing up post uni at the time. I went with mechanical engineering, like, all the top. Yeah. Nice easy topic. Oh, it's very simple. Yeah. Yeah. What could go wrong, right? Not easy at all.

James BenhamOkay.

Jay VindaSo I did that for four years, going on some pretty cool projects there. Went out to Peru for a couple of months, doing some volunteering work. I was building wind turbines for villages that didn't have access to electricity. That's a cool deal. That's pretty cool fun. And the whole time really kind of got instilled into me that I just love solving problems. Really learned how to tackle a problem head on. Came out of uni, couldn't find a job. So I thought, all right, what do I do?

Should I do with my time? Started applying for almost everything. And cyber security was one of the things I applied for. And just kind of picked up a grad scheme on it and thought, you know what? I'll do it for a couple of years. Let's see how it works. And then I'll maybe switch back into engineering. I came in at a really interesting point inside this game, a real inflection story. September 2016 is when I started. Just around the time the MirrorEye botnet started screaming out, which was this this this swarm of IoT connected devices just DDoSing, like, XKEME denied the service attacks on companies

James Benhamand Yeah. And for for the uninitiated DDoS, that distributed

Jay Vindadenial of service attack Exactly. Exactly. Where where a bot takes over a whole bunch of different machines and then slams traffic and basically waterboards a a server. Yeah. Exactly. And it's it's like the stuff that you're hearing Anthropic and OpenAI talking about now with the the claims of the big AI swarms where they basically thought that. But then, know, 2017, we had big ransomware attacks. Like, one if Ryan Loch Pessier hitting. Had Operation Cloud Topper as well where it was... He has a Chinese nation state backed espionage criminal group that is buying on ITMSBs.

And then zero day vulnerability just kind of causing half of the chaos. If you remember back in 2017, we all had this global issue of just, I'm using my laptop and it just blew springs of death randomly, constantly, every single time I use it. That was related to vulnerability with Meltdown and Spectre, which led to a lot of war rooms and a lot of panic and chaos trying to trying to figure out some not big fuse devices to open the screen at night all the time.

Yep. So it was really interesting time to join inside of Superiority and the tiers in the grad scheme and I thought, you know what? I like this place. I'm gonna stick it. I'll stick it out. Yeah. The rest of that was kind of history.

James BenhamYou liked that? And so did you get a did you get a graduate degree in cyber? I did. Yes. I did the mechanical engineering one first. That was an undergrad? That was... Then then grad school was in cyber? Yes. Did like an MEng in mechanical engineering and then

Jay Vindawhen I started working in cybersecurity, I then went back to uni while I was working as well. Wow. Did a MSc in information security. That was... You know, At the time, it sounded like a great idea, and then while I was doing it, I brought to myself.

James BenhamOkay. So we're gonna resume. So you you you were you were working, and then you were doing your your master of science in cybersecurity.

Jay VindaYeah. Information security. So did that for two years? It sounded like a great idea at the time, and it sounded like it was managed all. And then while I was doing it, I kinda sat there. I I remember doing my dissertation and still sitting there, and I was like, right. I've got a writer dissertation now,

James Benhamand I still got a job. It's like, why the hell did I do this to myself? That's pretty brutal. Yeah. That was not fun. Yeah. Not fun. That's pretty real. But you did it. If I did it, I got through that. Yeah. And then But that's good. Know, what I like about the engineering mindset is that fundamentally, you can be an engineer in any of the engineering disciplines, but it fundamentally teaches you problem solving. Yeah, that's it. I mean, is Engineering is problem solving. Problem At its heart.

Ideally, it's not regulatory compliance. It's

Jay Vindaproblem solving degree, so. I think that's big thing I'd say from it, right, is just the ability to kind of look at any problem and just say, alright. Well, how would I start trying to solve it? And quite often, I'll try and solve something. I didn't solve it, but it's just that ability to get started that I really liked.

James BenhamSo was the... It wasn't the same issue with cybersecurity that the idea of being the the good cop protecting

Jay Vindaprotecting folks from all these all these threats, or what what about it was really appealing to you? I think at first it was just quite a technical kind of discipline. It was... And quite fun as well. So when when I came into... This was our cybersecurity. We would build drones, pack drones, big boats. It's fun. Exciting. Why not? Right? And then within a couple of years, cyber security then became a mass... A massive board issue and Red Flagered to Become Blinds started here again. Cyber risk management started becoming its own discipline.

And suddenly it was... The the thing that was a really fun thing to do suddenly became a, hey, if this gets done really badly at a company, people could die or people get massively fired and so on. It was kinda like, woah, are they... Now I've got a job that actually means something, that actually that are really used to be thought about rather than, hey. I wanna build a joint and pack a joint because it's fun. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. It's it's serious.

James BenhamIt's... I mean, I think it's probably one of the most important technical professions in insurance right now Yep. Considering that insurance sits on the treasure trove and the honeypot Honestly, yeah. Of data. The amount of data has... Yeah. That has PII.

Jay VindaYeah. I mean, everything you'd ever need to hack the world is inside of Instrand's. Yeah. It's it's incredible. And it's... The thing that I find crazy is how... And I mean, you'll see when you look at all the vendors in ITC ways, there's loads of data and there's treasure trove of data, but the way it's been standardized and inflated and categorized, it's just not that great. Yeah. So insurers have loads of data, but they're just not using it very well.

James BenhamYeah. Whereas if you're cycling Well, they're not using it very well and... They're not using it very well for their own purposes, for good purposes. And and then, of course, a lot of other people want to use their data for them, which is dangerous and not good. Right? Not ideal, but There's

Jay Vindaways... There's, you know, there's there's there's some nice bits out of it. But Alright.

James BenhamSo let's jump let's jump in and and have a a a little bit more substantive conversation. I mean, your path into insurance was different. I'm... I appreciate you explaining how engineering led you into cybersecurity and led you into the field, and obviously, then your career in cyber led you into the honeypot of honeypots Yeah. Insurance, which makes, you know, a a ton of sense that that you would eventually wind up in financial services somewhere Yeah. Because it's such a big deal and, you know, banks obviously are the other parties that have just an incredible amount Yeah.

Of data that that... That's out there ready. Most of my cybersecurity background background was a financial institution, mostly with banks and a bit of government as well.

Jay VindaI did a little bit of insurance, but not loads. And I think, you know, after eight years of it, just kind of wanted a change of pace, change of scene. Having worked at banks, I got a tour. I I looked at the regulators and clients and the culture, if you will, with an organization, was kinda like, let's try insurance out. They they must be friendly. Yeah.

James BenhamWell,

Jay Vindalet's talk about Mosaic for a second. What does Mosaic do? So Mosaic is a specialist insurance company. They're based out... We've got regional hubs across six countries, but two Lloyd's syndicates that we underwrite on behalf of. So the thing that's unique about Mosaic is we underwrite on our Lloyd's syndicator, then also stretch out our capacity with third parties in the management partners. So essentially it's like that MGA model, except we have skin in the game on our loyalty to the favor as well. So for every risk, there's always- You share in the risk.

Yeah. Yeah, we share that risk. Yeah. So we always have 20 to 25% of the risk on our favor minimum. And what lines? So I think it's 10 lines now. Cyber insurance is the main one I obviously focus on, but I'll probably get it wrong, it's cyber political violence, political risk, environmental liability, professional liability, energy liability, litigation,

James Benhamso I don't know, stock financial institutions. Oh, it's all over the place. It's true mosaic of coverage. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. It's an actual mosaic. Mosaic is actually a mosaic. The name is pretty cool. The mosaic's appropriate. Yeah. Okay. So in... When when you say you primarily focus on cybersecurity, you're the CISO for the insurance company. Yeah. But you also focus on the cybersecurity insurance line. So explain how that works. Okay. So I have two reporting lines. I have one who's the chief operating officer

Jay Vindawho is our SMS 24. So she leads operational resilience for the organization. And my cyber security, so feeds into that for cyber resilience. And then I also report into the head of cyber underwriting as well. So cyber underlying, it's about 40 underwriters globally, spread across six countries. So it's about Canada, US, Bermuda, UK, Germany, and Dubai. And essentially, I do is I use my cybersecurity knowledge to help them improve how we assess individual risks for every risk that way you keep transferring to us, and then use threat intelligence to map out the types of scenarios that could make our portfolio of risks.

So you're doing for your insureds what you do for yourself? Exactly. Yeah. But then I also get to partner with the insureds as well and help them define what their strategy should apply. Because they have their own CSOs too sometimes. Sometimes they might not. And sometimes they don't. Sometimes the head of IT or it's someone legal and risk doing that. They'll title someone as CSO even though they're mainly head of IT. That happens a lot. They have to help. Yeah. Yeah. But it's it's good fun because you kind of...

You see a you see a whole broad set of companies. Mosaic typically is in the mid market and large corporate space, so kind of organizations revenues of $150,000,000 plus. This year we opened up our SME platform as well. So we're now searching that kind of 10 times a $50,000,000 revenue bracket where you just don't have a CISO in most types of companies. It's a lot of outsourcing to manage service providers and not necessarily the people with the expertise to challenge to really understand what their risk profile looks like.

So, you get a whole set of different challenges just for those insureds.

James BenhamSo at ITC, you're speaking about cyber risk through the eyes of a CISO Yeah. Which is good. I mean, from from your perspective, a CISO's perspective, which you wear two bulk apps. Right? You have you have was always fucking on the Yeah. You have your CISO hat for your company, and then you have your kind of your risk engineer hat for your clients. Right? Let's say from your CISO hat, what does that partnership look like in practice? And how can insurers help security leaders better understand, quantify, and reduce cyber risk?

I mean, Yeah. And so I'm asking you to kind of wear your CISO hat, but also your your risk engineer How

Jay Vindado you partner up with your clients and help them? So I think that's a really interesting bit here. It's one thing I'm really passionate about solving, if you mind me. Okay. So general assumption is a company wants to buy side insurance. Insurance buyer tends to be the risk packages. So someone in the CRO or the CFO's Yep. Are a lot motivating. Are chief legal officer. Yeah. Yep. But not the person who's day in, day out. Nope. Not a site dispute. Their motivation is get the best coverage of the most coverage with lower BBEs.

That's their motive. That's what they're going in with the broker to talk about. And that's what Perry is up to running capacity for. Now, the problem that you have is before the company's decided to buy cyber insurance, there's typically a risk management conversation a bit further ahead, where someone decides we have cyber risk, but we need to transfer alpha. And the person who made that decision or made the play to say the place to transfer it is someone who's got that cyber security mindset, who said, there are things that genuinely keep me up at night right now or things I'm just really struggling soulful.

I want to transfer out some flat rates. And right now, you've got a real big disconnect between the person who knows what could really go wrong and the person who's buying insurance coverage and, you know, having the conversation on what should the policy wording look like? What should the endorse talk? So do you play mediator to get them to talk to each other? Yeah.

James BenhamSo you're Yeah. So you're like part therapist

Jay Vindato help them talk to each other? I mean, honestly, it's my therapy as well, be honest. Yeah. Like when I go to like CISO conferences, we just call it CISO therapy at this point. It's just us all venting with each other, but it is genuinely like that as well. It's just going in there and making sure that the risk manager appreciates that the type of insurance they're buying, it needs to have the scenarios

James Benhamthat could materially go wrong with the organization. But that's so hard for them to stay up to date with. I mean Yeah. The the threat scenario right now is insane. It's changing all the time. Yeah. Like... But but, like, changing faster than I've ever seen it change. Yeah. I started writing software, building systems, and getting involved in the Internet when the Internet commercialized. Yeah. Nineteen ninety two, ninety three? Yeah. Before that, was on bulletin board systems. Okay. So we've had threats the whole time. Yeah. You know, lot of it was malicious viruses.

Yeah. Stuff The that goes on now is is wild because it's state sponsored, it's well funded,

Jay Vindait's well organized, and they run a lot like the insurance companies that that we work in. Or it's literally a criminal marketplace at this point. Yeah. You don't really need technical capability anymore. I'd say that the big cause of defining moment was in the past, you need to have the technical capability to operate your taps, but have that commercial mindset to monetize it as well. Whereas now, aside from you don't really need the technical capability. You just need funding to go to the marketplace and source and assemble the capabilities that you need.

You don't really need the commercial mindset either because you've got randomizer service operators who will take that on for you as well. So really, you don't need that much to to be a criminal. I think. And I think that's the the thing that's really changed the game here. It's not so much a capability shift. It's more just the capacity of people who could be cybercriminers has changed so dramatically.

James BenhamYeah. And they they needed less people. Yeah. I mean, they have their own open source models or open open weight models that they're putting on their own machines that

Jay Vindadon't have morality limits and Yeah. They don't have guard rails. They don't... They can, you know, they can just operate at will. You don't need to... Their emails are getting a lot better. Their text messages are getting sick. Yeah. They're they're... Synthetic voice work they're doing. I was reading something the other day where it's more for the Asia Pacific region where typically when they were looking at... When when when, like, a person moved in... I think it was Japan. Was trying to work out if an email was phishing or legitimate.

They just looked at how the characters were placed together because if I was trying to phishing email in Japanese, and I don't know Japanese, it's gonna come across really broken when a native speaker reads it. So that's how they just detect, oh, that's really broken. It must be phishing. But with generative AI, as about two to three years ago, which actually it seemed to by the end of life, we spun out, it became very easy to write in Japanese or in Chinese or in Korean and other native languages in in a in a script that just looked like a native speaker wrote.

So suddenly, just saw an uptick from high ASPs detecting malicious phishing emails that were working in a specific region.

James BenhamYeah. You know? It... They make sense. Because now you can write them perfectly. Yeah. Now I could write them perfectly. Yeah. You could too. It's great. Yeah. You you got threat vectors everywhere now. Yeah. It's... And they're and they're hard... They used to be easy to sniff out the

Jay Vindathe the schemes because the formatting was wrong. The images were wrong. The HTML was poorly formed. There was always this, like, sense of urgency every time as well. Whereas nowadays, I think what you find is that the starting conversation is there's no urgency, there's no ling, there's no... Very chill. It's just a... It's normally just to be like, I'll email you, but I'll pretend like I was emailing someone else. I'll pretend I was emailing someone with Jake. And you'll come back and correct me and say, hey, I'm James.

I'm not Jake. And I'll be like, oh, you're right. Oh, but anyway, now that we're chatting, why don't we chat a bit more?

James BenhamAnd it works. Yeah. Works. Well. Yeah. My cousin's a comedian and he's big now. But when he started, he had to find a way to get into the market. Yeah. And so he did this thing called crank text. Okay. And he would text from his cell phone thousands and thousands of thousands of numbers manually. This is twenty years ago. Yeah. So he just typed it in his phone. Saying do the numbers. Yes. And committing by one. Yeah. Yeah. Then he would just say, hey. What's up?

Yeah. Now this is how they're using now. This is what goes on now. Yeah. Then they would say, not much. Yep. And he'd cool. How are doing? One hour time. Yeah. And so it was a material percentage of people would engage in a pretty in-depth conversation with him, and they were hilarious. Of course, he's a comedian. He made it funny. And then he would screenshot the conversations and put them on his website. Yeah. And then, you know, use it as fodder in his next stand up bit.

But it's... It was amazing how many people engaged. Yeah. And it's amazing to me still how many people engaged. I think, like,

Jay VindaI think there's a a real concern at the moment across security industry, but across the discipline where we spent a lot of time trying to educate people and train people on what badge looks like. Just so... And and then it's almost become a bit of a liability shift of if you train your users, then it's their fault when something goes wrong. Right? But the reality is, and the way that the eye look is, if Mosaic gets taken down because someone clicks on a dodgy link, that's my fault.

If the whole company goes bust because of a link, that's not his fault. That's my fault. You need to plan that resilience and build that in and have that what we call defense and tech. And that's really kind of the crux of your job, isn't it? Yeah. It's just... I mean, it's really the fun. So my job is basically sitting there and thinking, alright. How would I hack Mosaic? What would I do to triple Mosaic? How would I impact our customers? And then be like, alright.

Well, how will I stop? So have you done a synthetic voice simulated attack? No. No. Not yet. Not yet. Pretty easy to It's do it's not hard. We did it at a previous shop in a red team. I... There's some open source tools out there that make it quite simple. Yeah. They're they're quite good. I mean, one thing that we kind of worked out is, you know, when you're trying to find, let's say, voice or videos of another person, you don't necessarily have to pull them and keep on the phone for a long time.

Just go on social media. People speak at conferences all the time and that gets published everywhere. Look at the company's internal marketing spot. What are they putting on Instagram and TikTok if everyone wants to be that next, know, up and coming market generator. Right? And then you just pick up these little snippets from there and you've got all your source material. Yep. Yep. It's real. It's insane. Yep. Yeah. The legitimate providers of simulated voice and video for people, if they wanna use it

James Benhamin ads, they make you validate and verify that you are who you are because they don't want their tool to be used, but there's a lot of other tools that don't do that. Yeah. So... Alright. So, I mean, we... We've got a couple minutes left. Like, what's your... I'll start on the negative side, then I'm gonna end on the positive side. What what right now, the 09/30/2026, what keeps you up at night right now? Biggest threats, biggest challenges, what what what do you, like, worry about?

Jay VindaFor me, a lot of it comes down to just the basics. There's a lot... So there's two issues with the basics. Right? The first one is there are very simple things that you can do in an organization towards excess health that are process based things, don't require big technology spend, but it just requires effort. A lot of effort needs to be put in to get a control to a position where it actually prevents a threat. One of the things that worries me is people would... People sort of seek the the easy alternative.

Oh, what if I just spend loads of money on this tool? What could be... There's so many tools out here that say they're AI powered cybersecurity or next generation AI cybersecurity, and it's just a lot of fluff that you're gonna spend money on that doesn't actually do what you need it to do. Yeah. And if you just spend the time and the effort just doing it manually, just putting in the effort and not trying to outsource your problem to another company and spend all that money.

Gonna solve it pretty quickly. I think data classification as data block probations are pretty big. It's on the back of the where you spend a lot of time trying to shift the data classification problem to other organizations. You say, oh, they can classify the data for me. They'll do. And it's really expensive. Take it that way. I'm just coming back and saying, oh, yeah. Outside of that, the other thing I was gonna say about basics is the goalposts just keep changing. We talked about... And he mentioned it.

Right? The threats from nineteen ninety two, ninety three to now just changed so rapidly. Wildly different. Yeah. Very different. I remember basics used to be you you used to have a really secure password. Now it's multifactor authentication, right? You need to have antivirus. Plus, plus. Yeah. Yeah.

James BenhamPlus the password less, plus the p Yes. Yeah. Yeah. And then two factor twice a day now. It was it was once a month. Yep. Then it once a week. Yep. Then it was once a day. And now it's all the facial ID as well. Now it's twelve hours. Mhmm. Now intra... Now hours for Mosaic. Yeah. Now it's all passwordless. Yeah. And Intra, and I mean, it's biometric. It's it's it's Yeah. You got The auth... Authentication authentication changed almost zero for decades. Yeah. And in the last two in the last two years, it went like, holy crap.

Yeah. I'm on Everyone needs 2FA. Yeah. 2FA, but not just 2FA. Yes. Yeah. 2FA passwordless biometric. Like, it's... We we are rapidly going to a point where there never anybody... Any passwords anymore. You know? Because you're you're... Your pass pass keys are becoming, you know, which which are fantastic.

Jay VindaYou know? Very convenient. Yes. I feel like... And it's also just, like, yeah, I have three tiers of passwords in my head for, like, they're really... The stuff I just don't care about are to, like, I really need to be... You to worry. But the thing that's really annoying for me is I've got that all in my hay while I'm going on the password plan. Yep. It's a master manager then. Is it vulnerable to itself? Yep.

James BenhamWhereas switching it all to biometric for the password, it just makes my life a lot easier. Yeah. Alright. So that's what you're most concerned about, what's keeping you up. Yeah. What are you most excited about?

Jay VindaFrontier AI, I think it comes up a lot as Buzz Webber. For me, looking across that platform, there's loads of hype out in the market about what funds your AI can do and we're all Gael's thief. I'd say for a cybercriminal, it's not really a game changer yet. Social engineering is still a very easy way to compromise company, to compromised identities. It works, and it's very cheap. Why would they switch the Frontier AI? A lot more expensive, those options are ticked off. But on a defensive use case, Frontier AI, the ability to detect zero day vulnerabilities You mythos.

Before their bad idea. Mean, mythos found twenty six year old vulnerabilities. Yeah. Holy cow. Mate, and all that tells us is... Well, first of I think there's two two things to take away. The first one is the types of reviews that we have today, code reviews, human reviews, security stress, and so on, did not detect it. So we thought a great step change there. The second bit is I don't believe that no one knew about this for twenty six years. It's more likely that people knew about it but just weren't willing to burn their zero day on it until they have to have a better opportunity.

Yeah. We're we're gonna find zero days that haven't been burned yet and have the best batch of a pizza before they get burned of InkStars, which is great.

James BenhamI'm most concerned about people doing stupid things. Yeah. Like, I... That's always what keeps me up is getting... People getting a phone call, and it's the gift card scam, which is so common. I have two, three friends who felt good... Fell victim to the gift card scam. One who lost their job over it. Okay. Wow. That's pretty serious. Yeah. It is. Yeah. And were they being stupid? No. Naive. I'd call it naive. Yeah. Trusting. You know? And and so that that keeps me up. Well, I'm most excited about the Frontier models as well.

I... I'll be honest. Like, I use it as a proactive pen tester, proactive security review. I did vibe code my jamesvenom.com site Yeah. Because why not? Yeah. Like, why wouldn't I? I love it. Yeah. I want something to play with that's mine. I have my, you know, I have my team, and they do all the other corporate sites. First thing I did Yeah. Is I went in and did a full bin test. It's it's quite fun as well. Yeah. And then I told it to dive 10 levels deeper.

I said, okay. I... You spent ten minutes. Yeah. I need you to spend an hour. Yeah. And then I did, like, max, you know, top edition, max effort. Yeah. Then I put a, you know, slash loop command, and I'm like, I really need you to dig deep and hard and try to get into the software. And it... I mean, it it came out with, like, 27 upgrades. Yeah. It was pretty remarkable. And so I... While I think that,

Jay Vindayes, the criminals have this, yes, so do we. Yeah. And I think that's a big thing that's really changed. Because the big, you know, AI and cyber security. It's not a brand new topic. I mean, I remember when I started back in 2016, AI was giddling security operations at Tuts. The thing that was really annoying is our risk appetite in the defensive side is just a lot lower than than a criminal's. For a criminal, if they use AI in offensive cyber operations and it doesn't work, cool.

Life moves on. They just do something else. It's not a big deal. Whereas for us, if we use AI to autonomously make decisions and it goes wrong, it's gonna hurt a lot. So AI is not new for cybersecurity defense. It's just we've gotten to a point where... And we've gotten to a point where offense criminal cybercriminals are just... That that the landscape is so asymmetrical in their favor that we're almost kind of forced to try this new thing. But we've also got much more trust in how it actually works.

We've explained it and understand it better so we actually know why it's baiting the decisions that it's making.

James BenhamI'll tell you this. It's it's the... It's... Maybe it's not the best consultant,

Jay Vindabut it's one of the best. It's... The thing that annoys me is there's massive people that ease up. Yeah. Oh, yeah. Oh my gosh. Everything I ask is like, Jay, that's so smart. You're so amazing. And now I just started ending my prompts with,

James Benhamgive me your honest opinion. And then it's like, this is great, but honestly, it's not that great. I've done... Yeah. I've I've done a I've done a lot of memory updates to Claude to get it to not be a sick of it. Yeah. So... But look. We've... We're at time. Thank you so much for coming on the podcast. I appreciate it. You know, this has been a great conversation, and I'm excited about you being in insurance and your first time in Vegas and your first time at ITC.

Good fun. I'm looking forward to it. And to all our listeners out there and listeners, thank you for tuning in today to geek out our episode and interview with Jay Vinda from Mosaic Insurance from beautiful London, England. Well, you'll see some more from us here at ITC twenty twenty six. Have a great day. Enjoy the ride and geek out.

Browse all episodes

Never miss an episode

Sign up for the InsurTech Geek newsletter and get new episodes, insurtech trends, and articles straight to your inbox.

The showAll EpisodesTopicsGuest DirectoryBooksAboutContactPrivacyTermsSponsor the showPitch a guest
ListenApple PodcastsSpotifyAmazon MusiciHeartRadioYouTube
FollowLinkedInYouTube