Skip to content
The InsurTech Geek PodcastEpisodesTopicsGuestsBooksAboutSponsorContactSubscribe
Bobby Touran
← Episode guide Episode 55

Better Distribution for Excess & Surplus with Bobby Touran from Pathpoint

Bobby Touran
Pathpoint
Published Apr 15, 2021
Runtime 50 minutes
Host James Benham
YouTube Spotify Amazon iHeart Apple

Bobby Touran

Bobby Touran from Pathpoint discusses the technology behind Pathpoint and their offerings for the excess & surplus sector.

Watch here

The full episode

Press play for the whole conversation.

Sponsored by
Terra
1

Connect with Bobby Touran

Bobby Touran Pathpoint Podcast

The full transcript

▸ Read it · 9,244 words

Transcribed automatically from the episode audio, so some names and terms may be misheard.

James BenhamJBKnowledge Podcast Network. On episode 55 of the InsurTech Geek podcast, talking about better distribution for excess and surplus with Bobby Touran from Pathpoint. The InsurTech Geek podcast powered by JBKnowledge is all about technology that's transforming and disrupting the insurance world. We'll be interviewing guests and doing deep dives into specific technologies we see changing the industry. We're taking you on a journey through insurance tech, so enjoy the ride and geek out. Alright, greetings and welcome back. Good to see everybody on the show today with me. Course, this is James Benham.

I'm with me, mister Rob Galbraith, most interesting man in insurance. Rob, how's it going in beautiful San Antonio, Texas today? It's going. Yeah.

Rob GalbraithYeah. Springtime is is here. Somewhat are you summer if you're not from Texas? Got into the nineties. I managed to get my first shot of the COVID vaccine yesterday with my family. So, interesting process. Arms a bit sore, but, yeah, happy to kind of get that.

James BenhamDid you do the drive through?

Rob GalbraithNo. It was it's kind of funny. So they've been sending texts from the government when they have open slots, which is kind of nice. And it turned out that it was like on the other side of town at some senior center or whatever. So we drove down there and, you know, they were backed up like an hour. So we stopped at at Popeyes and grabbed some lunch, and we're all fueled up. Wait. Did you get the chicken sandwich at Popeyes? Because there's a lot of the spicy chicken sandwich.

Yes. How does it compare and contrast the Chick fil A spicy chicken sandwich? Because it's better in my opinion. It's only the second time I've had it. I know. I know that's controversial, but it's super juicy. It's got tons of breading. I'm sure it is awful from a life insurance perspective.

James BenhamExactly.

Rob GalbraithYeah. So do my latter life policy before I Yeah. If if Rob's life insurance,

James Benhamright, is paying attention, just ignore that. He's not eating the Popeyes chicken sandwich. This is a subject of great debate in Texas, Bobby, is who has the better chicken sandwich. Of course, it's been a national debate. Everyone's trying to roll out a good chicken sandwich. That's hard to hear. Okay. I'm gonna I've been holding off on TriNet because I didn't have a friend actually personally attest to this, although a bunch of news pubs I read like Business Insider actually went and tested them side by side and they too declared Popeyes the winner.

So totally not talking about chicken sandwiches today though. We're gonna talk about excess and surplus and we're gonna do it with mister Bobby Turon. Bobby, what's up, buddy? Hey, guys. Thanks for having me. Yeah. Glad to have you. You're over in Northern California up in the North North Of The Bay Area. Yes. Thanks for waking up early and and joining the show with us. We super appreciate it. Pleasure. Thanks for having me. Yeah. And and, Bobby, you know, a a Boston guy, he's he's wicked awesome, thinks a wicked pisser.

He poxes kind of the odd. Now I I no one really speaks. Yes. They actually they actually do say that stuff. I I lived there long enough to know that they actually say those things, and it's a wonderful place. I'm actually a big Boston fan, so I'm excited to have Bobby on the show. Before we get started talking with Bobby, I just wanna remind you that you can subscribe to the podcast. If you're watching on Facebook or Twitter or any other video, Vimeo, wherever you're watching it, you can text geek out to 66866, and make sure you never miss an episode.

We'll email it to you every week. So hope you will subscribe and come and and enjoy the the podcast and all of our wonderful guests that we we've been doing this over a year now. Having a lot of fun, having a lot of great discussions around technology and insurance, talking about you know, a lot about automation. Right? A lot of automation, a lot about streamlining applications, a lot about using big data and public data sources. We haven't had a show on NFTs yet, although I feel like we should talk like a three parter on non fungible tokens just because it's such a popular topic and people are losing their minds over the price of NFTs for for things that I mean, this is just rampant speculation, Rob.

Right? I mean, I mean, you you know, NBA the NBA was so early to this NFT game, and I don't know. I I think NFTs are useful. I think all block I think any any any kind of blockchain or blockchain derivative is useful, but some of these prices that we're seeing, Rob, you gotta you gotta be a little mind blown. Yeah.

Rob GalbraithIt is crazy. You know, I try to suspend judgment on anything price related, but, yeah, not not personally investing yet in any NFT. But I agree with you. Like, I I I love the idea of crypto. We know Coinbase is going out with their IPO. Like, I definitely think it's a topic worth exploring in the future. Oh, absolutely.

James BenhamAnd, you know, this kinda kinda nutty stuff. Pay attention to Coinbase. If you haven't checked out Voyager, you can pay you can look at look at that. There's there's some fascinating things going on in crypto, but there's also fascinating things going on back here in excess and surplus. Then this this is a really important part of the insurance business, like an incredibly important part of the insurance business. So Bobby, before we jump in and talk about that, I want to talk about you. Again, Boston guy.

Went to got bachelor's in econ from McGill. So tell me about, you know, when you're growing up as a young boy in Boston, you know, looking up to Ben Affleck and all this other guy. No. When you're growing up as a boy in Boston, what what'd you want to do and how'd you end up doing this? I was always interested in being a business owner.

Bobby TouranAnd at the time, I didn't really know what that meant. Nobody in my family is a business owner. My parents are both teachers. And so very different background. And when I graduated college in 2008, more and more normal people like myself were starting startups in the Boston area and in lots of places, And it had been going on long before that too. But that's when I first became aware of it. And a lot of those startups were based on the internet. And what was exciting to me was that, you know, folks were starting an online store for whatever product, but they would have no experience in selling anything or certainly not that thing or doing anything online.

And just the fact that it was kind of open to everyone was intriguing to me. So I started basically hanging out around incubators and other software entrepreneurs and just kinda got pulled into the industry

James Benhamand haven't really looked back since then. Yeah. And and you actually spent some time with some venture firms, it looks like, and you were an entrepreneur in residence, and then you you were an associate. So it looks like you actually spent some time funding companies. Is that correct?

Bobby TouranWell, funding, yeah, I guess. It wasn't money coming out of my pocket, but I was No. Out of your firms. Yeah. Two successful investors. Right. Doing doing a lot of the busy work, getting to learn how companies are evaluated, and just spending time digging into the problems that early stage company founders face, which was frankly fascinating. And I'd studied finance in college, so I was interested in kind of the intersection of investing and startups. And as I spent more and more time with the companies, I just realized that I was very interested in being an operator.

And so then transitioned into a role where I tried to incubate an idea on my own. Yeah. So you've how how did you arrive at insurance?

James BenhamLike, what what about this industry? What about the I mean, I just just an FYI, Pathpoint. So it's pathpoint.com. You guys buy non admitted policies online immediately. Right? That's the that's the the the entire the entire I just summed up the whole thing for you. We're we're gonna deep dive on what that really means. But how did you arrive at this particular problem statement? Was it one of the investments that you looked at when you were on the investing side or was it know, what what what about this really really tweaked your interest?

It wasn't, you know, originally

Bobby Touranbaked into my GPS, so to speak. It wasn't on my road map. If if I went back a couple years, we've been myself and my cofounders now have been building this company now for about four years. And if you went back four years in a month, four years in two or three months, I wouldn't be telling you that, you know, insurance is sort of what I want to spend the rest of my life working on, just because I didn't really know about insurance. And as me and my team got introduced to the industry in more depth, we just found it fascinating.

And one thing that we saw over and over again was that it seemed like the process was super manual, quite inefficient, and we just felt like there wasn't a ton of software being used. So that felt like a good entry point for, you know, folks like us who didn't really know much about insurance, but who had a good idea of like how to build and sell software. So it was really the leveraging what we were good at and something that we didn't know, that was interesting, and then really just got started and just kept making progress from there.

Yeah. It's really a

James Benhamrecurring theme on this podcast is we we saw a lot of manual tasks being performed and not a lot of automation and not a lot of use of data and a whole bunch of menial tedious work. And in particular, all of that sums up into a super non ideal customer experience. Right? I mean, you have to fill out a bunch of Word document or PDF forms and then wait forever to get pricing, and then binding as well takes time. And it just it just seems like an incredible amount of waste in the entire the entire insurance ecosystem, unnecessary waste.

Right? And so you have a choice. I'm I'm curious. You you have a choice when you're starting a company to either start a software company or and and sell to insurance companies and help them do this, or you have a choice to actually become the insurance company, either the broker, the MGA, or the carrier. Right? Those kind of your that's like your your. You know? Like, you can go be a broker. You can go be an MGA and and have power of the pen, or you can go actually raise a ton of money and be a carrier.

So you you almost have, like, four choices. Right? Just be a technology vendor or be one of the other three. What led you down the the broker path of being a surplus lines broker? Why'd you pick that instead of just being a technology supplier or going down the MGA route? Well, from the start, our customer

Bobby Touranwas always the carrier and the sort of the way that happened was that a lot of our earliest conversations were with participants from each of those buckets that you just listed. Distribution, delegated underwriting, carrier based underwriting, whatever you'd call it, and also the software vendors. And you're totally right. There's a lot of inefficiency, and there's still even with a lot of good companies out there, there's a huge amount of improvement to be made still. And we knew that we wanted to have a role in the distribution chain in order to meaningfully or sorry, should say the value chain in order to meaningfully bring about some value and some change.

And so we looked at those options, like you said. And being a software vendor just felt like it was not involved enough. And it would have really changed just sort of the nature of our business, like different sales cycle, different types of personnel. And while that's closer to what we, myself and my co founders, have as backgrounds, we were just very interested in trying to improve the distribution. And in excess and surplus lines, the distribution is super concentrated in just a few brokers. And so there's this, like, very long tail of a lot of other regional brokers who are constantly clawing to keep up and then eventually just sort of get bought up.

To us, that seemed like the more dynamic part of the industry where we could play a role. Plus, we're not underwriters.

James BenhamAnd so to assume a role as an MGA or as a carrier would just have been a much bigger leap for us. Yeah. You would have had to do some pretty senior experienced hires to bring to bring some talent in on that, and then you're still you're taking a good bit more risk as well, you know, and and just liability. Right? Exactly. And so it's the broker path is certainly an easier starting point. Yeah. It's easier in the sense that it's like, you know, you

Bobby Touranbasically offer shelf space or you offer a store and then you get these carriers to give you their products once you've built some relationships and trust with them. But distribution is not easy either. I mean, work really, really hard to get coverage for their clients. And like we're saying, because it is quite manual and inefficient, a lot of that inefficiency falls on the agents. And so, you you mentioned buying non admitted policies online, just sort of the language we use on our site is very much focused towards independent retail agents and, making it easier for them to basically get coverage for their clients.

Yeah. Get it quickly. Less work. Less work, more option, ultimately lower cost.

James BenhamYeah. And that that's something that a lot of brokers really struggle with is there's a big, big, big sector of the market, big, big sector of the market that's not very profitable to write for them Right. Because of the amount of time it takes to collect the data and get the quotes. And you're really just kind of playing the odds that, hopefully, those customers will keep getting bigger and keep buying more insurance and buy more more lines lines from you, and eventually, it'll work out. Like, you'll make enough money to justify all the time.

And so a lot of brokers I found, they take the business. They don't do a great job on the business because they don't have, the amount of time it takes. And then for them, if they don't have enough companies pop up into the larger sec segment, they don't take the time on the on the the the smaller accounts to keep cultivating them into large accounts. And so they end up running a lot of business off. And it and it all comes back to how much time it takes them to to process quotes and binding.

I mean, really, if you look look at it, if they if they were more efficient and effective at collecting data from their clients and then getting pricing from the market and then binding the, you know, the the the core function of a broker. If they had if they really shrunk that down, they could provide a a great level of service to more of their clients. Right? I mean, you end up really with some subpar service being delivered to smaller accounts. Yeah. I mean, one of the things that we've seen over and over again is that there's this spectrum of size of insurance account.

Bobby TouranAnd based on that size, there's an increasing amount of premium that's associated with each of these accounts. Yep. Not necessarily more complicated to place a small commercial account than it is to place a middle market account, or even in some cases, a large market account. It's complicated in the sense that you need different carrier relationships and you need a different customer base. But like you're saying, if you're a local insurance agency,

James Benhamit can be tough for you to move upmarket.

Bobby TouranAnd so you kind of have to just be very efficient at the transactional stuff if you want to be profitable and grow your business. And that's really what we saw as the big opportunity, and that's why we're at least initially focused on what's going on at the smaller end of the spectrum in terms of the size of these accounts. Because it isn't necessarily more work, but it is necessarily less money to the agent. And so they're further incentivized to

James Benhambe as quick as possible. Awesome. So let's I love Rob's question he's got going up because, it kinda breaks this down into some more, more explainable terms for some of our audience. So, Rob. Yeah, Bobby. So,

Rob GalbraithI really wanna hone in on the you know, we talk about E and S or excess and surplus, talk about non admitted markets, and maybe you can just give our audience a sense for the types of exposure, the types of risk. Right? So these are not things that are typically approved by a state regulator. This is not your traditional commercial auto, internal liability, etcetera. So maybe you could just Who are the types of carriers on your platform and what are the types of exposures? Obviously, of the challenge of E and S is it can be a lot of things.

Things like Uber that started out, right? It didn't fit in a traditional model, and so they went to the E and S route and became huge. So maybe you can just give our audience kind of a flavor of what type of risks are we talking about here? Sure. So the excess and surplus lines industry plays this critical role. And like we were saying earlier,

Bobby Touranit's this industry that very much operates in sort of like I like to think of it as operating in the background of the commercial and personal lines insurance industry. Most people don't think about risks going to the E and S industry. But E and S, in a way, is really where a lot of insurance was born. Right? Because one of the biggest players in E and S is Lloyds of London, and that's where, insurance was originated and when underwriters were taking bets effectively on whether a ship would make it across the ocean or not.

James BenhamWait. By the way, wouldn't you have wouldn't you love go back in time to this to this coffee house? And just I would. Just be and just be a fly on the wall and watch this completely unregulated industry.

Bobby TouranBasically gamble on these boats. Yeah. And it wasn't I mean, it wasn't even an industry then, like you said. Right? It was it was a coffee shop where you could literally go get some action on a boat that's that's going across the ocean. You don't have to know about boats or know anything else, but you just wanted to go be with your buddies and and do something to pass the time, I guess. But the market today plays an incredibly important role for risks that are more distressed than other risks, risks that are riskier than other risks.

And I think when a lot of people think about like Lloyd's and if they have some knowledge of ENS, they think about the super risky. Right? They think about the the complete one complete end of the spectrum. They're like, oh, it's only you know, we were talking about sports earlier. It's like, it's only a baseball it's only a pitcher's arm that gets insured in the ENS market or or something like that. And and, the reality is in the E and S industry is supporting a lot of businesses that are all around us.

If you're a bakery, you probably don't need E and S insurance. If you're a bakery within a mile of the ocean, you probably need E and S insurance because have less control carriers have less control over what could happen to you within that one mile. But from the perspective of a business owner, they don't really know, oh, the risk is going to be E and S or not. They don't really necessarily make decisions to start their business or not on that basis. But to get coverage for that type of risk, the traditional retail agents have to work with surplus lines agents or wholesale brokers.

And that just adds additional process, which means more manual paperwork, more time, less efficiency, and ultimately making it more difficult for the agent to give their client what they need. So, we focus on E and S risk existing into two very, very big buckets, sort of the P and C industry and then the professional lines industry. Within P and C, we're laser focused these days within general liability and specifically thinking about businesses like contractors, lessors risk only, vacant land. These are the types of businesses that go to the E and S industry in a non pandemic environment.

And in the last twelve months, the E and S industry has played an even more important role because a lot of admitted carriers were pulling back from business that they would normally write because there was so much turmoil in the markets. And that was really an opportunity for the E and S market to step in and say, those are the types of risks that we're happy to write. Risks that have less underwriting data and legacy associated with them, risks that could potentially be more loss bearing, but that ultimately makes sense for that carrier based on sort of the profile of their underwriting DNA.

So we make some of those PNC products available as well as property or catastrophe exposed property. That's another common one. So here in California, if you have wildfire or earthquake insurance, those are examples of ENS insurance on the property side. If you live in Florida, if you live in Texas, you need wind coverage or flood coverage due to the environment. And then on the non P and C side, things like cyber insurance, which is a very hot topic right now, professional miscellaneous professional liability, D and O, other forms of E and O, coverages like that tend to fall within the E and Ss.

Y'all do a really good job, by the way, of really clearly explaining who you are on your website.

James BenhamOkay. It's just I I wanna I wanna congratulate you. Not every company that we look at has such a a clear distinct mission. I just wanna read this. This is just a a statement from your website, opening a new avenue to non admitted insurance. As a surplus lined brokerage, licensed countrywide, and cover holder at Lloyd's of London, Pathpoint distributes admitted and non admitted products to independent retail agents on behalf of best in class non admitted carriers across multiple lines of business. I mean, so the that that's the the summary, but but let's let's talk about the carrier part of that sense.

I have talked about this in the some previous episodes. I've recently I'm a pilot, so I have to get coverage for me in in my plane, and and it it it gets complicated. The aviation market is really, really complex. I'm guessing I don't see you playing in aviation on your site, but I'm guessing you don't you don't play in the aviation market. It it's a it's a really weird, unique, little niche of the of the insurance business, there's fewer carriers. There's three fewer carriers than there were a year and a half ago.

I have recently become personally aware of how important your broker's relationship with the carriers is because I I got some really awful quote, and they they all say they write with the same carriers, but I got some really terrible quotes with one guy. And then I went to a different guy, and he had a much better relationship with the underwriters, and he was able to get me far better pricing and really sell the risk better. Want me talk talk about that because we we talk a lot about technology on this this show.

Right? And and and Rob has a a question come up about tech, and and it it's a it's a really good question that I'd love to geek out on the the what's under the covers. Despite if you take all the tech aside, how are you forming better relationships with these carriers so that they're giving more attention or better pricing or better coverage or more time or giving it more credence to the the risk that's that's coming through you rather than everybody else? How how are you tackling that?

Bobby TouranI think one of the things that we have going for us is just that digital trading and selling insurance products more efficiently through the use of technology is on the mind of every insurance carrier. And they're all looking to reduce cost. You know, the because it has that additional level of distribution through the surplus lines channel, has a particularly high expense ratio, just generally speaking, higher than traditional business because there isn't as much distribution consideration that has to be baked into it. Because it's a top priority, we're able to get a pretty good audience with even very senior level folks at these carriers.

We absolutely spend real time and money. I myself spend a lot of time building personal relationships with our carriers. You know, we started the company almost four years ago, and for the first two and a half years, we really only worked with one carrier who we built a great relationship with, and whom we really learned about the industry from. And then and only then did we start having conversations with other carriers. But today, we have over 10 carriers with whom we have appointments whose products are available through the platform.

And some of those carriers I've been talking to for four years, and they've really only come on the platform recently because it's that relationship building aspect

James Benhamof it. Are they happier with the qual I mean, there's gotta be some and and, you know, I've talk to enough underwriters. Right? There's gotta be some of this is you're you're hopefully preparing a better submission. Right? Like, a better quality submission. Like, the the data you're providing, the format you're providing it, the completion, the the completeness, the quality of of the data in the form. Is is that what this is coming down to? Like, they're just seeing a much better quality

Bobby Touransubmission coming to them, so they're willing to spend some more time on it? Yeah. Exactly right. And again, back to what you were saying on the spectrum of products from small to large and how agents don't want to spend a bunch of time on these smaller risks, that sentiment is true from the agent all the way through to the carrier. Carriers don't want their underwriters spending time on small risks. And, you know, the common expression is if you touch some of these pieces of business twice, you're already losing money on it.

So what happens is because there isn't an efficient way for these carriers to receive submissions, Almost 100% of the submission volume in the industry happens just over emails sent to inboxes. So when those emails come into these underwriters, they don't really have a good way to filter through the risks because it's all unstructured data. It's all emails with attachments as a PDF or loss runs or whatever. So, underwriter is gonna have to open that up, gonna have to look at the details. So, they're spending time on this account.

Very, very likely they're gonna realize that a key piece of information that they need to underwrite that account is not available because a lot of carriers have different requirements. And so they're gonna ping that agent back through the wholesaler and say, hey, looks okay, but I would need to know these three values. And if the wholesaler comes back and only gives them two values for example They're done. And the underwriter is gonna still have to open that up again and be like, oh, my guy emailed me and it's only two of the three things I need.

Can you get me the third piece? By that point, most wholesalers are gonna go away because they too don't really wanna spend time touching this risk. So there's this like misalignment. And if there was a standardized way for them to get the data, like you said, to underwrite the business, everyone could be more efficient, but it's tough. It's a it's a difficult challenge for sure. Fascinating.

Rob GalbraithLet's talk about the tech, Rob. Yeah. So I think you've outlined some of the challenges really well, Bobby, but what did you do at Pathpoint? How did you help solve this problem? I think about, you know, we mentioned Lloyd's of London. I've been to the insurance library in Boston, which is an amazing place. Yes, there is such a thing as the insurance library. And they do a wonderful job up there. And they actually have an old underwriter desk right from Lloyd's of London. They're kind of on display.

And that's what we think about. And I know it was a big deal during the pandemic when Lloyd's rent remote for a time and they kind of have their blueprint on how they're going to get digital and automate over time. And I think there's a lot of you know, initial positive reviews, but also some skepticism that this is an area of the world that will ever, you know, become digital or automated. Yeah, how did you crack the nut? You know, everyone yes. Wants that streamlined process, but they also want what they want to evaluate risks, right?

And we think about them as being somewhat bespoke and special and you can't automate away the underwriter. So, yeah, how did you crack the nut? What specific

Bobby Touranthings did you have to implement from a tech standpoint to enable your solution? Yeah, so we looked at exactly what you were saying. What's the process for how these agents are placing the business today and how could we make that more efficient? I don't know if it's super innovative, what we did from the outside. I think under the covers is where it gets a lot more compelling. But basically, we looked at other sectors of insurance, not just commercial or P and C. On the personal line side, homeowners, auto, life, most of these insurance products are available through a single point of submission, digital platform, a SMC platform, whatever you'd call it.

And most insurance carriers have their own portal, which is a way for them to digitally receive risk information. Typically, what they'll do is they'll put their underwriting details on the other end of that platform, and when the risk comes in, it bounces back with rate information. So that's essentially what we did for the excess and surplus lines industry. And to date, nobody is really offering that directly to retail agents. So to just clarify a bit more about the insurance part of what we do, is important to the tech part, we are a licensed surplus lines agent.

We're licensed in all 50 states. We service accounts once they've bound. So, we calculate surplus lines taxes. We make sure the accounts are in good standing. We're a cover holder at Lloyd's. So, agents working with Pathpoint can bring business into Lloyd's today through our digital platform. But that all kind of sits in the background. All these retail agents that we work with have to do is go into their web browser. They don't have to download anything, and they can just enter their risk information from a single application.

And then we've done all the mapping and business logic on the back end to route this information to the different carriers and return quotes from multiple E and S carriers to retail agents. And that's something that no one else is offering these retail agents right now. So, we have this differentiated value proposition. We know that there are competitors out there who are working on this kind of thing, and we think that's great because that's gonna make more carriers wanna digitize their products. It's gonna make it table stakes for this type of business to be traded digitally, And those are that's a rising tide that will raise that will raise our ship as well.

But to I guess to more tactically answer your question, we really just got started with, you know, a single product that we thought could be made, that we could streamline. We looked at how many questions are asked if you go to multiple different carriers. Can we streamline that and just give agents a web form they can fill out? And then we built some tech around it to make it easier for them so they can drag and drop. We looked at, like, what are the key parts of the process and the pain points.

All agents were telling us, and we do everything we build is based on what agents tell us as far as feedback. We try not to make any assumptions ourselves. That's where we get into trouble. So it's I don't like to spend all day long rekeying the same information over and over into different portals. I don't like having to wait days, sometimes a week plus, only to hear back from my wholesaler that, Sorry, no luck. Like, why couldn't they have told me that sooner so I wasn't chasing them on this, especially in this small account?

I don't like having to maintain all of the records associated with a submission across my email, my text message, a napkin where I wrote something down at lunch. I want it to all be in kind of one place. And so a digital platform was just an elegant way to do that. And again, it was working in other parts of the industry. And our vision was if we can be the digital platform, we effectively become the digital exchange for this type of business. And that's sort of the big vision for what it grows into as we add more products and more capabilities.

Rob GalbraithFollowing up on that, Bobby, I'm just kind of curious, like, what is on the roadmap? We focused a lot on on non admitted, but I believe you do some admitted products as well. And, yeah, just kind of curious, like, it seems like you're you're just getting started, but, you know, you kinda talked about expanding your carrier relationships and and new products. So, I guess, where do you see that going over the next three to five years? Yeah. Over the next,

Bobby Touranyou're right that we do offer some admitted, coverages. Those are offerings from carriers that are non admitted in some states, but then admitted in others. And one of the things that makes commercial insurance, all insurance really challenging is that it's regulated at the state level, as you guys know. And so every state has different That's

James Benhamlike the core problem in The United States in general insurance.

Bobby TouranYeah. It's one it's one of the big headaches. Right? And We could just make the entire InsurTech Geek podcast about why state regulation is a massive challenge for any progress at all in this industry. It's not only is it the case that it's state regulated, right? Four states, New York, California, Florida, and Texas, I mean, that's over 50% of all E and S dollars right there. And they just have very different ways of operating. But anyway, our focus is really exclusively and has been exclusively since day one on the non admitted or E and S market.

There's a lot of competition on the admitted side for things like BOP and comp and making it more streamlined to place that business, which makes a ton of sense. There should be solutions around that, but that's just not what we're focused on. We'll continue to try to make the best product available always. We think about it in terms of what are the products we need to offer. And I think of products like contractor general liability, LRO on a monoline or package basis, monoline property, you know, pretty basic categories.

And then how many carriers do we really need to offer coverage from to offer a comprehensive solution to the agent so that they're going to have options they can show their clients. So, the roadmap is really to deepen what we're doing within the segments that were live and to add a couple other key segments within PNC and and non and non PNC lines of coverage. That's fascinating. So let's talk about the actual,

James Benhamlike, the guts.

Bobby TouranNo emails are being used to to communicate with the carriers. Are you still having to package some of this up and send and email some of the packages out? Yeah. Absolutely. We we have to do that. 100% we do that. I mean, we don't do it a 100% of the time. And this is true of, like, all early stage software companies is there's always some degree of human intervention that's happening behind the scenes. A lot of people, when they see what we're doing, they can react with, like, well, hang on.

That's my job you're talking about. Like, my job is to to move these papers around. Like, is what you're saying is that you're gonna take my job away? And the answer is genuinely, and I realize everyone hears me say this is gonna say, well, of course, that guy's gonna say that. That's really not the objective. The objective is to make you better at the actually challenging parts of your job, like making go no go decisions on risk, like following up on a complicated billing issue, like doing whatever you have to do to make coverage needs of your clients to make sure that the coverage needs of your clients are met, you should not be spending 50% of your time shuffling papers.

When we were first getting started, I went to the offices of a very large MGA that is far and away the market leader in a particular category of risk. And, you know, they're heralded as being so efficient, so tech forward. And, when I went to their office, they had three floors to the office. And I said, you know, the manager walked me around and he was like, here's our underwriting floor. And I was like, great. What do these underwriters do most of the time? And he looked at me and like, without any hesitation, he's like, well, they spend at least 50% of their time just opening emails and reentering the information into our system.

And I was like, oh, that's interesting. Why not build a system that you give to the folks so that your folks would get 50% of their time back? He thought about it and it was obvious that like he's thought about that before, but he but he just really didn't have a good answer. He's like, well, that's, you know, it's complicated and, you know, we don't really know where to get started. And back to your question, we That's

James Benhamconnect the dots. Mind blowing. I'm sorry. You just, like, you dropped fifth half of their time. That's right.

Bobby TouranKeying data from email. And this is the market leader in that particular line of coverage. They write several $100,000,000 a year in that type of exposure. And yeah, that's just the norm. And now mind you, they're doing a lot of bigger placements, so there's a lot more meat on the bone in each of those transactions. But even on the small stuff, there's a huge amount of intervention. Our goal is that we don't have to use emails for doing that type of quoting. And some players in this space, it basically comes down to almost being like a religious decision as an online distributor of product.

You can either decline everything that doesn't fit the box, so you only rate automatically, or you're on the other side, you sort of have a very general definition, you'll kind of take a look at anything, or it's somewhere in between. And we constantly, you know, as getting started, we have to give a good experience to those agents, We have to kind of go and do more manual work than we would ultimately like to be doing. But that's how we build that initial rapport with the agents.

James BenhamYeah, that's

Bobby TouranNot to forget, one other thing that I think is important, and this is something I tell folks all the time is there's a lot of great companies out there building better, smarter ways to get data. So, like, companies that will use drones to more effectively look at, like, what's the quality of roofs on property that's being underwritten. One of the that's great, and that absolutely has to exist. And the fact that, you know, most flood insurance in the world, in the country at least, is still underwritten based on dated flood maps, you know, tells you kind of everything you need to know.

The reality, though, is that the majority of carriers who I have interacted with are not necessarily thinking I mean, they're thinking about, but they're not set up today to plug in really advanced data into how they work. It's just not how their formulas are set up, and they would basically have to redo their formulas. And at the end of the day, like, that's what underwriting is. Right? It's a valuation and assessment of a risk. So, as much as we would like to be able to only send things digitally, again, because this is E and S, things are just not black and white.

A huge amount of the business is just sort of in this gray area. And like that's a yes, no question. There's always gonna be some dialogue. So we hope to minimize that as much as possible, But my guess is that over the next several years, there's always going to be a place where we have to sort of go outside of the box, so to speak, to make the coverage actually to make the transaction out. Sure. And, you know, mind you, I've spent the last two decades in Jamie Knowledge building

James Benhamproprietary in house software for carriers and brokers and TPAs and PBMs, helping them facilitate these transactions. A lot of them really don't like how email heavy their business is. They they really don't. And and the last few years, there's been a big awakening in a lot of their minds about trying to dramatically reduce the amount of manual rework that's being done, reentry, rekeying of data. It's really quite quite absurd. It's all driven by you're you're right. A state driven regulatory structure and a lack of any technical standards whatsoever.

You know, it's the the the fact that a PDF form in a in a court is still the de facto standard for who has what insurance is is you know, at least accord exists. Right? I mean, because we we we work in other countries where there is no adherence to accord, and and those countries, it's just a free for all trying to figure out and interpret all your documents. So it it's real it's really fascinating. The good news for all of us technologists is it creates enormous amounts of opportunity for us to come in and deliver an enormous amount of value because there's so much low hanging fruit, you know, when when half of a person's time is spent rekeying data and really talk about the one of the most important roles in the whole damn company and and those people are that that's why it really does blow my mind when they say, you you're trying to limit my top.

No. No. We'd like you to write a lot more business. We'd we'd like to keep the same amount of people and write a lot more business because they they're passing up on good risk all the time because of data reentry. And they they can have so much more profit. It's really astounding. Rob, what you got? Yeah. No. I

Rob Galbraithlove where both of you guys are going on this, and you're right. In fact, it's funny. I'm reading a book right now about automation in the 1960s, if you can believe it, and this fear that automation was going to take everyone's job. And I guess this was an issue in like the presidential campaigns or, you know, Kennedy and Nixon and things like that. So that just kind of goes to show you that we're really a long way off from a lot of those considerations. In fact, there was a big newspaper strike when the New York Times bought the first IBM mainframe computer and they had to like fortify the floors in the building because this thing was so heavy, right, to be able to bring it in and all that.

And they were saying that people didn't get newspapers for three months because all the union, it wasn't just the Times, the Post, and others were going in there. It was all the typesetters and all that, they were all worried about automation taking away jobs. Certainly, you've seen the decline of newspaper and people get their news differently and things like that. But, yeah, I mean, this has been just such a long running concern. And quite frankly, we know we're a growing industry. We know a lot of people are retiring.

We know we don't have the young people entering our industry that, you know, are going to be able to replace every single one of those people. So we definitely need the efficiencies that technology are going to bring just from that kind natural attrition. And, oh, by the way, when I talk to college students and others, if you were to introduce them to the job that 50% is rekeying, they are going to walk out the door of your enterprise very, very quickly and move somewhere else. So, yeah, I think these things can absolutely kind of coexist, right?

There's technological efficiencies and improvements. And yet you're still going to need the expertise that people have built over the years because it is a specialized industry, particularly as we've been talking about, Bobby, in the non admitted world. So, I think it's just fascinating. I love the fact that, you know, you've kind of indicated, Bobby, that it sounds like you're not having to do a lot of convincing of folks when you're introducing Pathpoint to them, that they're almost coming to you to seek out the solution or certainly when you are reaching out, that you're finding receptive ears.

I don't know if that's been changing over time or if you still get resistance from the retail agents or the carriers at all, or if everyone kind of gets it, they're just looking for that easy way to digitize and you're the solution that they've been looking for already.

Bobby TouranWell, we hope that we're the solution that they've been looking for, and we're constantly trying to evaluate and keep ourselves honest, know, on whether or not that's true. For the retail agents, there's no cost to use Pathpoint. There's no minimum placement amounts required. We pay you commission when you buy in business just like any other wholesaler, and we pay competitive commissions. Not to mention that it's faster and easier and all those other things that come with it. So the sell to retail agents is pretty straightforward.

It's there's no risk to using this. It's gonna make your life better and you haven't had this before. And then, you know, if you make a submission into Pathpoint with a non admitted submission as a retail agent, you can submit within a minute or two and you get a bindable quote back instantly. Right? So that same submission, if it was being placed in the most advanced non Pathpoint way today, the fastest you're gonna get a bindable quote is maybe a couple hours if it's a fire drill.

But for 95% of submissions, it's going to take days or maybe even a couple weeks for like a thousand or $2,000 premium policy. So the sell to agents is pretty straightforward, but we're always trying to find new ways to engage with agents and bring them onto the platform. For the last year, wholesalers trip typically a lot of insurance agents in the commercial sector, they'll get a book of maps for those who's listening, who knows what a book of maps is, and they'll get into a rented car and they'll drive around to different insurance agencies and they'll say, hey, here's what we have to offer.

How can we work together? We've done a lot of that onboarding remotely via calls like the Zoom calls and demos and things like that. On the other hand, carriers, it's a different story. This is not an industry where you have thousands of carriers, right? It's a small universe. And really when you boil it down, there's just a couple dozen that write the vast majority of all the business. And those carriers have other people, other distributors knocking on their doors. And one of the things we really are always thinking about is how can we message what we're doing even more clearly to folks?

Because they hear, oh, you're E and S, but you're a digital platform, and they just haven't heard that. So they're like, so do I have to get my wholesaler to use you guys? Or like, how does it work? And that's something that we're always trying to improve. But generally, you know, I can I've only been in the E and S industry now for about four years. And I've seen huge changes in the attitudes of carriers and agents towards this type of thing,

Rob Galbraitheven just over the last year or two. Awesome. That's awesome. Hopefully, this podcast will help you. Yeah. Hopefully so.

James BenhamAnd guys, great discussion. Bobby, really appreciate you

Rob Galbraithdiving down the rabbit hole with us on this topic. We do have two new stories that that Rob's brought to the table today. I want him to cover before we wrap up. Rob, what you got? Yeah. So first one is funding, and and it's been a continual theme, James, that, you know, we saw a dip in q two right when the pandemic hit, but it really picked up in Q3, Q4. It continues. The numbers haven't come in from Q1, and obviously, just started Q2 in 2021.

But ClearCover announced this week that they've raised a $200,000,000 Series D round. So for those of you that aren't familiar, ClearCover basically sells auto insurance online. And one of the things that I love that their companies talked about is this idea of negative innovation, taking out all the stuff that you don't need of saying, hey, auto insurance is actually a personal auto, pretty simple product. Like we're not going to spend a ton of money, millions of dollars, multimillions of dollars on advertising or flow and the gecko and all that.

Right. We're only going to provide you what you need and we're going to try to be a low cost provider. I kind of liken them to the Southwest Airlines of auto insurance. So congratulations to the team at ClearCover on the Series D round. And then again, we're starting to see Insurtechs acquiring other Insurtechs. Fris, which is based in The Netherlands and does a lot with fraud detection and AI on the claims space, they've acquired Terrine Labs to expand their underwriting capabilities. And Tareen Labs provides a lot of third party data as well as artificial intelligence to help from submissions and other things that we've been talking about.

And so I just find this trend fascinating. Again, not new in any way, but just continuing this trend of more mature and sure tax joining forces through M and A activity to get even bigger, stronger, offer more. And so I think it just speaks to the resilience of the Insurtech world, they're here to stay. Sure does. And they're they're here to stay and they're maturing.

James BenhamAnd it's they're certainly many of them are edging into much larger markets and having a much, much bigger impact. And so it's exciting to watch, having having, observed this space for many, many, many years, to to see that, there's fundamental corners of the market that are that are that are transforming now, not just the not just the outskirts. So real really, really, really exciting. Well, Bobby, thank you for joining us today, I appreciate you being on the show. Thank you both very much. And I'll be rooting for your patriots, and they have a good year this year just like I'll be rooting for my saints.

Bobby TouranYou know, that that that's a it's a good good to root for your hometown teams. Right? Well, Patriots have a lot of room to improve in this season, so it shouldn't be too hard for them to do better. But Yeah. I know. Thanks very much for having me on. This was a pleasure, and look forward to keeping in touch with you guys as

James Benhamas we grow. Awesome. And Rob Galbraith, as always, thank you very much, sir. Always great to be on with you guys, James and Bobby. It's a pleasure having you on this week. Great. And thank you. This has been the InsurTech Geek Podcast powered by JBKnowledge. It's jbknowledge.com. All about technology. It's transforming and disrupting the insurance world. I've been your host, James Benham, jamesbenham.com with cohost Rob Galbraith, endofinsurance.com. Big thanks to Jim Greenlee, our podcast producer, Cara Daltonaro, the creative producer, and thank you for joining us today.

We're taking you on a journey through insurance tech. So enjoy the ride and geek out. See you next time.

Browse all episodes

Never miss an episode

Sign up for the InsurTech Geek newsletter and get new episodes, insurtech trends, and articles straight to your inbox.

The showAll EpisodesTopicsGuest DirectoryBooksAboutContactPrivacyTermsSponsor the showPitch a guest
ListenApple PodcastsSpotifyAmazon MusiciHeartRadioYouTube
FollowLinkedInYouTube